Corn Muffin w Raspberry JamMoist, cornmeal muffins with a seedless raspberry jam center.
$3
Cinnamon RollPetsi's weekend classic, slathered in cream cheese icing.
$4.50
Chicken Hand PieOur famous chicken pot pie filling baked and perfect for one and ready to travel!
$8.50
Box of 6 Scones
$20
Box of 6 Cookies
$16
Box of 6 Muffins
$16.50
Banana Chocolate Chip MuffinMade with fresh bananas, these light and fluffy muffins are studded with mini chocolate chips.
$3
Mini Scone Sampler BoxThis box of scones allows sampling of the 3 Petsi classics: buttermilk currant, lemon glazed & triple berry for small and large crowds.
$30
Muffin Sampler BoxFeed the crowd with these 3 muffins flavors (4 of each): Fresh blueberry, corn with raspberry jam & banana chocolate chip.
$33
Bacon Cheddar Scallion BiscuitBig and hearty, our famous biscuits are loaded with bacon, cheddar and fresh scallions.
$4.50
Dark Chocolate & Apricot CookieBits of dried apricot, chunks of bittersweet chocolate and just a touch of (decaf) espresso make this cookie so very special.
$2.75
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$2.75
Snickerdoodle CookieButtery and soft sugar cookie rolled in cinnamon sugar.
$2.75
Ginger Molasses Cookie
$2.75
3-Pack Cinnamon RollThese beauties come in packs of 3, covered in cream cheese icing. Weekends only!
$12
Blueberry MuffinThese tasty not-too-sweet muffins are packed with fresh blueberries!
$3
Box of 6 Blueberry Muffins
$17
Box of 6 Bacon BiscuitsGet 6 of our giant and very famous bacon cheddar scallion biscuits - sharing optional!
$25
Scone Copy
$4
Tres Leches CupcakesA bakery favorite! Vanilla cupcake soaked in a sweet blend of the traditional three milks and topped with our very own creamy caramel frosting.
$5
Smoked Pecan Butter CookieInspired by Texas bBQ, this cookie is a perfect balance of smoky, salty and nutty. Its sweetness comes from caramelized brown sugar flavor with deep brown butter notes. Yee haw!
$2.75
Pie of the Month
Salted Caramel Apple PieFilled with our classic blend of local apples and caramel, topped with a lattice crust and a sprinkle of sea salt.
$12
Fresh Baked Sweet Pies
Pumpkin PieThe fall classic consistently gets high marks for a quality spice blend and the use of honey instead of sugar, which better balances the sweet with the savory squash.
$12
Chocolate Bourbon Pecan PieOne of Petsi’s signature pies, this luscious bittersweet chocolate filling has a hint of bourbon and topped with toasted pecans and a chocolate ganache.
$12
Classic Apple PieFilled with the perfect blend of locally grown Granny Smith and Cortland apples, seasoned with a hint of cinnamon and sugar and topped with our original buttery flaky pie crust
$12
Mississippi Mud PieRomance the chocolate lover in all of us, this sinful seducer is made up of quality imported Belgian chocolate, brownie streusel and a chocolate glaze in a chocolate cookie crust.
$12
Blueberry PieWild Maine blueberries and a touch of cloves topped with a lattice of our buttery pastry crust.
$12
Brown Butter Pecan PieAn old family recipe, our Southern-inspired pecan pie is out-of-this-world delicious, it boasts a rich filling loaded with pecans, baked in our crisp and buttery pie shell..
$12
Apple Crumb PieFilled with our classic blend of local apples and topped with our rich buttery crumb topping.
$12
Cherry Crumb PieMade with tart Michigan cherries and topped with our buttery crumb topping.
$12
Mixed Berry PieFilled with blueberries, raspberries and blackberries, mixed with a tiny bit of sugar and topped with our buttery crumb topping.
$12
Savory Pies
Roasted Vegetable & Kale with Feta PieOur vegetarian quiche is loaded with roasted butternut squash, kale and a buttery, locally made feta cheese for a balanced, savory bite!
$12
Bacon, Leek & Gruyere PieClassic quiche filled with sautéed leeks, shredded gruyere and topped with crispy bacon.
$12
Spinach Artichoke w Jasper Hill cheesesThis savory pie is a spinach artichoke dip crossed with a quiche! Creamy spinach filling studded with artichoke hearts and topped with aged cheddar and aged Alpine cheeses from the renowned Jasper Hill Farm in Vermont.
$12
Frozen Take & Bake Pies
Chicken Pot PieSold frozen and unbaked, this classic savory pie is completely made from scratch. Starting with roasting whole Mayflower Poultry chickens, a decadent gravy is made with homemade stock, adding potatoes, carrots and peas and lots of love.
$14
Vegan Pot PieDairy-free double crust pie filled with lentils, potatoes, carrots, broccoli, onion in a tomato mushroom gravy. Comes frozen and unbaked.
$14
Take 'n Bake Classic Apple PieOur 10" classic apple pie frozen and unbaked, ready to pop in the oven whenever pie is needed!
$38
Take 'n Bake Mixed Berry PieOur 10" mixed berry pie with crumb topping, frozen and unbaked, ready to pop in the oven whenever pie is needed!
$38
Take 'n Bake Vegan Apple PieOur 10" vegan double crust apple pie, frozen and unbaked, ready to pop in the oven whenever pie is needed! Serves 8-10.
$38
Take 'n Bake Vegan Apple Pie - 8"Our 8" vegan double crust apple pie, frozen and unbaked, ready to pop in the oven whenever pie is needed! Serves 4-5.
$24
Take 'n Thaw Brown Butter Pecan PieOur treasured pecan pie family recipe is available baked and frozen, ready for you to thaw and eat. Serves 6-10.
$40
Take 'n Bake Cherry Crumb PieOur 10" cherry crumb pie frozen and unbaked, ready to pop in the oven whenever pie is needed!
$38
Take 'n Bake Apple Crumb PieOur 10" apple crumb pie frozen and unbaked, ready to pop in the oven whenever pie is needed!
$38
Take 'n Bake Vegan Mixed Berry Pie - 8"Our 8" vegan double crust mixed berry pie (raspberries, blackberries & blueberries), frozen and unbaked, ready to pop in the oven whenever pie is needed! Serves 4-5.
$24
Take 'n Bake Vegan Mixed Berry PieOur 10" vegan double crust mixed berry pie (raspberries, blackberries & blueberries), frozen and unbaked, ready to pop in the oven whenever pie is needed! Serves 4-5.
$38
Take 'n Thaw Chocolate Bourbon Pecan PieOur signature chocolate pie is available baked and frozen, ready for you to thaw and eat. Serves 6-10.
$40
Take 'n Thaw Pumpkin PieOur 10" pumpkin pie is available baked and frozen, ready for you to thaw and eat. Serves 6-10.
$40
Take 'n Thaw Key LimeOur 10" key lime pie is available baked and frozen, ready for you to eat frozen OR thawed! Serves 6-10.
$40
Take 'n Bake Cauliflower Cheddar PieThis frozen savory pie heats in the oven in under 45 minutes and packed full of cauliflower, cheddar, thyme and a touch of Dijon in a crispy hash brown potato crust. Vegetarian and gluten-free but not celiac-safe.
$36
Petsi Merch
Tote BagTote your Petsi Pies around! This handy bag is 13" w x 15" h x 10" d
$5
Petsi Pie ServerStainless steel pie server etched with the Petsi Pies logo.
$20
TeesGet your Petsi swag! New Petsi Pies Logo on front right. Ivory color, new design for 2026!
$18
Petsi Pies HatsGet your Petsi swag! Our Petsi Pies hats come in orange canvas or light blue trucker.
$15
Candles
$4
SweatshirtGet your Petsi swag! New Petsi Pies Logo on front right. Ivory color, new design for 2026!
$40
Youth TeesGet your Petsi swag! New Petsi Pies Logo on front right. Ivory color, new design for 2026!
$15
Tea TowelGet your Petsi tea towel! Features an absorbent material for efficient drying and a stylish design to complement any kitchen decor. Crafted for durability, it ensures long-lasting performance with everyday use.
$10
Handmade Greeting CardBlock print handmade cards for every occasion!
$6
Petsi Pies Diner MugThis classic 10 oz Diner Mug is made from durable ceramic, it features a glossy colored exterior and matching glossy interior for a stylish, high-quality finish. Hot beverages never tasted so good!
$15
Catering
Breakfast Pastry PlatterA delightful assortment featuring our mini muffins, mini scones, coffee cake and fluffy baked donuts.
$55
Coffee Break PlatterA delightful assortment featuring our mini cookies, bar cookies, and seasonal teacakes.
$55
Box of Hot ChocolateOur house made hot chocolate is one-of-a-kind, cravable with a touch of cinnamon. Comes in a 96 oz box with cups.
$25
Box of Coffee (hot or cold)96 ounces of medium roast Fazenda coffee or cold brew (serves 8-12). Comes with cups, half & half, sweeteners and stirrers.
$20
Earl Grey Tea (hot or iced)Beverage box holds 96 ounces of fresh brewed MEM Earl Grey tea. This beautiful black tea with bergamot contains caffeine, comes with milk, sweeteners, cups and stirrers.
$20
Crimson Berry Tea (hot or iced)Beverage Box holds 96 ounces of fresh brewed MEM crimson berry tea. Unsweetened and no caffeine. Cups and sweeteners included.
$20
Chai Tea (hot or iced)Beverage Box holds 96 ounces of fresh brewed MEM Ras Chai tea. This spiced black tea contains caffeine, sugar and comes with milk and cups.
$22
English Breakfast Tea (hot or iced)Beverage Box holds 96 ounces of fresh brewed MEM English Breakfast (black) tea. Contains caffeine. Comes with cups, whole milk, sweeteners and stirrers.
$20
Menu
Donut
$3
Matcha
$4.50
Vegan Pies
Vegan Apple PieFilled with the perfect blend of locally grown Granny Smith and Cortland apples, seasoned with a hint of cinnamon and sugar and topped with a dairy-free flaky pie crust.
$12
Vegan Blueberry PieWild Maine blueberries and a touch of cloves topped with a dairy-free flaky pastry crust.
$12
Vegan Cherry PieClassic cherry pie made with Michigan cherries and topped with a dairy-free flaky double crust.
$12
Vegan Mixed Berry PieFilled with blueberries, raspberries and blackberries, mixed with a tiny bit of sugar and topped with a dairy-free flaky double pie crust.
$12
Specials!
Gracie's SWEET CREAM Ice Cream"Located in Union Square, Gracie’s Ice Cream is a peddler of smiles and homemade ice cream" and is a beloved long time neighbor. Their delicious Sweet Cream Ice Cream is the perfect complement to any sweet Petsi Pie.
$9
Whipped Cream14oz Cabot Whipped Cream to accompany any delicious Petsi Pie.