Best Italian food in Buffalo
462 places · updated Nov 2026
#1
Jet's Pizza
4.6 · 115 ratings#2
Broadway Pizza
4.6 · 18 ratings
460 more · not ranked yet
- $4.50–58.85
- $4.25–55.30
- $3.80–125.95
- $9.25–92
- $3.75–51.99
- $10.99–49.99
- $13.49–79.99
Just PizzaNew York Style Cheese & Traditional Cheese & 1 Topping Pizza +84 more $3.50–46.95- $3.83–128.05
Campobello's#1 Large 1-Topping Pizza + 10 Wings or 5 Fingers +78 more $5.50–92- $4.25–97.65