Single BagelA single bagel to take home. Not sliced or toasted. All of our bagels are boiled and baked fresh every morning.
$2.50
Half Dozen Bagels6 bagels to take home. Not sliced or toasted. All of our bagels are boiled and baked fresh every morning.
$13
Dozen Bagels12 bagels to take home in a bag. Not Sliced or Toasted. All of our bagels are boiled and baked fresh every morning. *Does not come served on a platter with cream cheese.
$25
Frozen Bagel (3 Packs)Choose a 3 pack of our signature kettle boiled and baked sliced and frozen bagels!
$4
Cream Cheese Tubs
8oz - Plain Cream CheeseServes 4-5
$4.75
8 oz - Specialty Cream Cheese8 oz of our Specialty Cream Cheese. All of our specialty flavors are mixed fresh in-house. Serves 4-5
$7
8oz - Butter8oz of the same salted butter we use on our sandwiches! Serves 20-25
$4
Single Serve Cream Cheese3 oz of our house-mixed cream cheese. The perfect portion for a single bagel or to try a new flavor!
$2.50
Bagels with Spread
Bagel with SpreadA fresh bagel with your choice of a topping.
$2.50
Sandwiches
Egg SandwichA folded egg on a fresh bagel of your choice. Customize your sandwich to add any meats, cheeses, and/or toppings.
$6
Bagel & LoxA fresh sesame bagel with St. James Nordic Reserve Smoked Salmon, cream cheese, capers, & red onion.
$14.50
The TaterA fresh everything bagel with egg, bacon, scallion cream cheese and a hashbrown. Kinda like a baked potato, but a breakfast sandwich.
$11.75
Turkey Bacon ClubA fresh sea salt bagel with turkey, bacon, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
$10.50
BLTA fresh plain bagel with bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo
$9
Avocado "Toast"A fresh, toasted sesame bagel with avocado mash, olive oil, coarse sea salt, and smoked paprika.
$7.50
The B-O-XA fresh buffalo bagel loaded with Sahlen's ham, melted cheddar cheese, a hashbrown, and topped with Frank's hot sauce! *Our Buffalo Bagel is a plain bagel dipped in hot sauce and topped with cheddar cheese!
$9.50
Pizza BagelCup & Char Pepperoni, Mozzarella Cheese & Pizza Sauce, piled on and cooked to perfection!
$8.50
Build Your OwnBuild your own bagel sandwich. If your sandwich contains egg, please use the "Egg Sandwich" option.
$4
Sides
Kettle Chips
$2
Hash Brown Patty
$1.50
Side of Ketchup
Side of Hot Sauce
Pickle
$0.40
Side of Bacon
$3
Side of Sausage
$3
Side of Egg
$2
Fall Drink Specials!
Pumpkin Swirl Nitro LatteSpiced pumpkin puree and white chocolate sauce layered with our in house brewed & infused Nitro Espresso, milk, and finished with cold foam and pumpkin spice.
$5
Apple Pie Nitro LatteApple syrup layered with our in house brewed & infused Nitro Espresso, steamed milk, and finished with cold foam and cinnamon.
$5
Pumpkin Nitro Cold Brew
$5
Maple Sugar Nitro LatteMaple syrup and in house brewed & infused Nitro Espresso, milk of choice, and topped with maple sugar. Our maple syrup and maple sugar are produced locally by Maple Glen in Gowanda, NY.
$5
Salted Maple Cold BrewOur house-made Nitro Cold Brew layered with Maple Syrup and topped with salted sweet cream cold foam.
$5
Cozy ChaiOur house-made Chai mixed with white chocolate and cinnamon powder.
$4.75
Hot ChocolatePittsford Dairy Chocolate Milk & Chocolate Sauce steamed to order and topped with whipped cream and chocolate drizzle
$3.50
Signature Drinks
Bagel BrewOur version of the NOLA! House-made Nitro Cold Brew layered with Pittsford Dairy's Chocolate Milk. Served over ice.
$4
Iced Strawberry Vanilla MatchaSmooth and creamy matcha over Strawberry Puree & Vanilla Syrup with milk of your choice. Served over ice.
$5.50
Salted Maple Cold BrewOur house-made Nitro Cold Brew layered with Maple Syrup and topped with salted sweet cream cold foam.
$5
Nitro White Chocolate Latte
$5.25
Drinks
Hot CoffeeLocally Roasted Columbia Beans by Undergrounds Coffee House.
$3
Hot TeaVariety Of Harney & Sons Tea.
$2.50
Nitro Cold BrewHouse-steeped for 20 hours using locally roasted beans from Undergrounds Coffee House.
$4.50
Nitro Latte
$4.75
LemonadeHouse Made Lemonade
$2.50
Chai Tea LatteSpiced Tea Concentrate, brewed in-house and topped with creamy steamed milk. Available hot over over ice.
$3.50
Matcha Tea LatteSmooth and creamy unsweetened matcha. Sweeten it up with your choice of syrup! Served with milk over ice.
$4.75
Jug-Of-Joe96 oz (10) 8oz cups of Underground Coffee's Columbia Blend, the same coffee we serve in the shop! Please allow additional time at pick-up as the coffee is brewed fresh to order.
$20
From The Cooler
Orange JuiceNatalie's Orange Juice is deliciously squeezed from one ingredient only: oranges. No preservatives, artificial ingredients, added sugars, or GMOs. It's the bright, boldly fresh way to start your day.
$3
Apple Juice
$2.50
Spindrift Sparkling WaterBubbly Sparkling Water (12 oz)
$2
Chocolate MilkLocally produced by Pittsford Dairy (16 oz)
$3.50
Iced TeaPure Leaf Tea (Sweetened or Unsweetened)
$2.50
PopCan of pop (12 oz)
$2
Bottle Of WaterAquafina Water Bottle (20oz)
$2
Oatley Barista Oat MilkThe perfect dairy free pairing for our half gallon Cold Brew or Chai Concentrate!