SammyChoose up to two cookies, one ice cream, and up to two toppings!
$7.50
Scoop of ice creamChoose your ice cream and up to two toppings!
$4.50
6 cookiesHalf dozen cookies in a box. Choose your flavors!
$15
Catering cookie tray50 of our most popular flavors in smaller 2.5" cookies! Perfect for a gathering at home, the office, or to stress eat on your own! Trays include: Chocolate chip, Confetti, Oreo Chocolate chip, and Double chocolate chip
$50
Sundaechoose your cookie and ice cream flavor and up to 2 toppings!
$6.50
Iced Sugar Cookies-catering50 2.5" buttercream iced sugar cookies. Please let us know of your color choice in the comments section of the checkout screen.
$60
Half Sammy
$4
Big A** Stuffed CookieWeighing in at more than a half-pound each, the BASC is two extra-large cookies stuffed with all kinds of goodness! There is only one BASC flavor each week check out Facebook to see what amazing flavor this week.
$6
Cookie CakePlease choose your desired cookie flavor and decoration preference. Additional details can be added to the notes section at check out (include the color of icing you would like included, as well as the message you would like on the cake). MUST ALLOW 36 HOURS.
$15
Skillet AT HOMEA perfect sweet treat and you won't even need a babysitter! Date night kit includes: a cast iron skillet, cookie dough, and a pint of ice cream! Cookie dough will be chocolate chip. You can choose your ice cream flavor and we will have it ready when you come pick up!
$15
Cinnamon Rolls
**GLUTEN FREE** Cinnamon Rolls-4 Pack-Pickup 8/22/26GF Cinnamon Rolls for pick up on Saturday 8/22 from 9-11 or after we open for the day at noon. THESE WILL NOT BE READY UNTIL 8/22/26 AT 9:00 AM REGARDLESS OF THE LIES SQUARE TELLS YOU VIA EMAIL OR TEXT...can you tell it's not doing what I want it to do?!
$20
Cinnamon Rolls-6 Pack--pickup 10/2 or 10/3Cinnamon Rolls for pick up FRIDAY 10/2 after 7:00 PM or SATURDAY 10/3 after 12:00
$25
Cookies by the Dozen
One Dozen Cookies - Individually wrappedOne dozen individually wrapped cookies. Select your cookie type using the modifiers below. Most cookies can be made Gluten Free. After your order is received, I will contact you to confirm delivery date. Please allow 48 hours.
$28
One Dozen CookiesOne dozen cookies in a box. You choose the cookies!
$25
After Dark Events
Paint and Sip: Cookie Cake Edition 8/1Your ticket includes a cookie cake, icing to decorate it, drinks and a fun night out at Cincy Sammys After Dark!
$25
Menu
Pay what you wantChoose your quantity to adjust your price. We ended up overloaded with cookies after a rained out (basically) Heritage Festival. We don’t want them in the trash.
$5
Baking Class 8/9 Junior (ages 8-14-ish)A kid friendly version of our baking class! Drop the kids and enjoy an hour and a half of peace while we learn more about baking! They’ll even have cookies ready and waiting when you pick them back up!
$40
Baking ClassJoin us for our first Big A$$ Baking Class: Baking Basics Bootcamp on 7/26 from 1:00-2:30 in the afternoon! All ingredients and equipment provided. Hands on instruction Cookie troubleshooting guide Fresh baked cookies Dough to bake at home