Bagel & Cream CheeseOne of our housemade cream cheese spreads on your choice of bagel.
$4
Bagel & ButterFreshly baked bagel with butter.
$2.50
2 oz. SpreadAn individual 2-ounce container of one of our housemade spreads.
$2
Single BagelBagel, plain and simple, with options to slice and toast. *If you'd like butter, please choose bagel & butter. If you'd like cream cheese, please choose bagel & cream cheese. If you'd like egg, please choose egg sandwich.
$2
Bagel Sandwiches
Pizza BagelGarlic butter, pizza sauce, and provolone on your choice of bagel. Option to add pepperoni and/or banana peppers.
$6.25
Custom *No Egg* SandwichBecause not everyone wants an egg on their sandwich. Build your own creation with all the meats, cheese, and veggies you want.
$3
BLTDouble bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on your choice of bagel.
$6.75
Smoked Turkey SandwichLucius Q smoked turkey, housemade onion chive cream cheese, lettuce, and tomato on your choice of bagel. Option to add bacon for the full turkey club experience!
$7.50
Italian SandwichHam, pepperoni, banana peppers, onion, tomato, and jalapeno garlic cream cheese on your choice of bagel.
$7.50
NYC LoxLox straight from Brooklyn on your choice of bagel with plain cream cheese, capers, onions, and tomatoes.
$11
Avocado Bagel ToastFresh sliced avocado on your choice of bagel with lemon juice, sea salt, red pepper flakes, onion, and tomato.
$7.75
Beverages
La Croix12 oz. can
$1.50
Bottled Tea18.5 oz. bottle, choice of unsweetened or sweet
$3
MilkHorizon Organic, 8 oz. carton
$3.50
Chocolate MilkHorizon Organic, 12 oz. carton
$3.50
Bottled Water16.9 oz. bottle
$1
Orange JuiceTropicana, 12 oz. bottle
$3.50
Apple JuiceTropicana, 12 oz. bottle
$3.50
Coke Zero12 oz. can
$1.50
Gatorade20 oz. bottle
$3
Sprite12 oz. can
$1.50
Coke12 oz. can
$1.50
Diet Coke12 oz. can
$1.50
Extras
Miss Vickie's ChipsChoice of sea salt, sea salt vinegar, BBQ, or jalapeno.
$1.75
Chocolate Chip Cookie with Brown Butter and Belgian Chocolate
$3
Hash BrownOne crispy hash brown patty
$2
Egg Sandwiches
Queen CityFresh cracked scrambled egg, Glier's goetta, and American cheese on your choice of bagel. If you would like to make substitutions, please create your own bagel sandwich.
$8
SouthwesternFresh cracked scrambled egg, sausage patty, pepperjack cheese, jalapeno garlic cream cheese, banana peppers, and red onions on your choice of bagel. If you would like to make substitutions, please create your own bagel sandwich.
$9.25
The GardenFresh crackled scrambled egg, Swiss cheese, roasted vegetable cream cheese, lettuce, onion, tomato, and red bell pepper on your choice of bagel. If you would like to make substitutions, please create your own bagel sandwich.
$8
Bacon AvocadoFresh cracked scrambled egg, bacon, sliced avocado, and Sriracha sauce on your choice of bagel. If you would like to make substitutions, please create your own bagel sandwich.
$8.50
The GECCOGlier's goetta, fresh cracked scrambled egg, cheddar, and chive & onion cream cheese on your choice of bagel. If you would like to make substitutions, please create your own bagel sandwich.
$9
The SkilletA whole diner breakfast piled on a bagel! Fresh cracked scrambled egg, bacon, American cheese, a hash brown, and ketchup on your choice of bagel.
$9.50
BYO Egg SandwichBuild-your-own style! Fresh cracked scrambled egg on your choice of bagel, with option to add cheese, protein, and/or veggies. If you don't want egg on your sandwich, please choose the Custom *No Egg* Sandwich instead! *Our egg sandwiches run through a conveyor oven by default, so only select double
$5
Take Some Home
Tinker Coffee - 12 oz. Coffee Beans12 oz. single origin beans from Tinker Coffee Co. in Indianapolis, IN.
$15
8 oz. SpreadAn 8-ounce container of one of our housemade spreads.
$5
Brunch Bundle12 cold-proofed, kettle-boiled bagels of your choice + 2 tubs of housemade cream cheese. We will do our best to accommodate or communicate with you if we are out of certain flavors. Please indicate in the text field below what count of each bagel flavor you'd like, and a few backup flavors in case w
$25
Half Dozen Bagels6 cold-proofed, kettle-boiled bagels of your choice. Please indicate in the text field below what count of each bagel flavor you'd like, and a few backup flavors in case we've run out. We will do our best to accommodate or communicate with you if we are out of flavors. We can only accommodate up to
$10
Dozen Bagels12 cold-proofed, kettle-boiled bagels of your choice. Please indicate in the text field below what count of each bagel flavor you'd like, and a few backup flavors in case we've run out. We will do our best to accommodate or communicate with you if we are out of certain flavors. We can only accommoda
$18
Coffee Box96 oz. of freshly roasted and brewed Tinker Coffee in a cardboard carrier. Choose add-ons below.
$30
Lox - 2 oz. Portion2 oz. (individual) portion of smoked Atlantic salmon from Acme in Brooklyn, NY. Packaged in clear plastic to-go container. Order several for a great bagel spread at home!
$6
Hot Water Box96 oz. of hot water in a cardboard carrier. Choose add-ons below.
$10
Menu
Who Dey T-Shirt"Who Dey Think Gonna Eat Dem Bagels" on a heather black Bella Canvas t-shirt.
$10
Who Dey T-Shirt (Oakley)Your two favorite things in this city: Bengals and bagels. "Who Dey Think Gonna Eat Dem Bagels?" on a heathered black Bella Canvas t-shirt.
$10
Logo T-ShirtFor the ultimate Bagelry lover. Heathered black Bella Canvas t-shirt with turquoise Bagelry logo.
$20
Bagel Maxxing Pink
$20
T shirtGray t-shirt with turquoise bagel-patterned pocket. Available in small, medium, large, extra large.
$10
Bagel Maxxing White
$20
Coffee / Hot Drinks
Hot ChocolateGhirardelli, 12 oz. cup
$3
Hot TeaTazo, 12 oz. cup
$2.50
Iced Cold Brew CoffeeOur new house cold brew coffee over ice.
$5
12 oz. CoffeeTinker Coffee Indianapolis, Single Origin, Medium Roast
$3
16 oz. CoffeeTinker Coffee Indianapolis, Single Origin, Medium Roast
$3.50
Iced LatteOur new house cold brew topped with whole milk, served over ice, with option to add flavored syrup.