Best Italian food in Columbus
603 places · updated Nov 2026
#1
Paulie Gee's Hampden
5.0 · 23 ratings#2
Jet's Pizza
4.6 · 115 ratings
601 more · not ranked yet
- $7–29.99
- $5.25–100
- $12.99–29.99
Loiee G’sBuffalo Chicken Pizza Slice +66 more $2.65–25.99Castello PizzaLG ONE TOPPING PIZZA, 1 PHILLY STEAK, FRIES, & 2 LITER +65 more $6.99–59.99- $5.74–14.99
- $4.99–22.99
- $6.65–26.30
- $1.99–65
PastariaVolare Mushroom Trio over Penne +55 more $2.99–60- $7–27