Kid ScoopOne, 3 oz scoop of your flavor of choice!
$3.95
CookieAn individually packaged cookie of your choice!
$3
Spooky Pumpkin Pie SundaeA personal ghost shaped pumpkin pie served with pumpkin ice cream, hot caramel, whip cream, graham cracker dusting, & a cherry
$8
Worms in Dirt SundaeA scoop of Cookies & Cream served with hot fudge, gummy worms, whip cream, and a cherry
$7.50
Cookie Box (cart)
$15
Coffee Cake SundaeA Coffee Cake Cookie served with Coffee Ice Cream, Cinnamon Glaze, Whipped Cream & a Cherry
$8
Ice Cream
Single ScoopOne, 4.5oz scoop of your choice of ice cream
$4.95
Double ScoopA Double scoop of ice cream in the flavor of your choice.
$6.25
Triple Scoop9oz of your choice of ice cream!
$7.75
Puppy CupA scoop of vanilla yogurt, with a dog treat on top!
$2.50
Regular MilkshakeYour choice of ice cream spun into a shake, served with whipped cream and cherry
$7
Hot Fudge SundaeTwo scoops of vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, nuts, whipped cream and a cherry
$7.50
Brownie SundaeOur homemade brownie, two scoops of ice cream, a topping of your choice, whipped cream and a cherry
$7.75
Large MilkshakeYour choice of ice cream, spun into a milkshake
$8
Build-Your-Own SundaeYour choice off ice cream served with two toppings, whipped cream, and a cherry
$7.50
Pint of Ice CreamTake home a pint of your favorite ice cream! We hand pack each 16oz pint fresh for you.
$9.50
Sticky's Merch
CREWNECK TEEThis super soft tri-blend crew neck tee is the perfect way to rep your favorite ice cream shop! Care instructions for longest life: Machine wash cold, inside-out, gentle cycle with mild detergent. Tumble dry low. Cool iron inside-out if necessary.
$24
Sticky's Ice Cream BeanieHow do you show you love ice cream in the middle of winter? With an ice cream beanie of course! This cozy knit hat features our ice cream cone with eyes, letting everyone know where you spend the summer months. Available in 2 colors, this hat makes the perfect gift for the ice cream lover in your li
$15
STICKY'S MUGEnjoy your favorite warm beverage, or a scoop of ice cream, in this ceramic mug!
$8
STICKY'S SWEATSHIRTSuper soft crew neck sweatshirt with Sticky's logo on front. Color: Vintage Navy Content: 50/50 Cotton/Poly
$45
STICKYS BASEBALL CAPRep your favorite ice cream shop with the embroidered cotton baseball cap! With an adjustable strap in back, one size fits all.
$15
Bakery Items
Donut CrittersEnjoy a dozen glazed cake donuts in fun critter shapes. Finished with the glaze of your choice & two sugary eyes.
$24
Buckeye platterEnjoy a platter of our homemade buckeyes! This classic Ohio treat is sure to level up any tailgate or celebration.
$15
Single Cookie
$3
Freshly Baked CookiesA box of our homemade cookies, baked fresh for you! Available in a variety of different flavors.
$8
Monthly Specials
Buckeye SundaeEnjoy Buckeye Fever Ice Cream topped with Hot Fudge, Peanut Butter Sauce, Whip Cream, & a Peanut Butter Buckeye!
$7.50
Pumpkin PaintingJoin us for some fun Pumpkin Painting at our Galena location! Paint a pumpkin and then enjoy your favorite ice cream flavors. When: Sunday October 4, anytime between 2-4PM Where: Sticky Fingers Ice Cream, Galena Location, 5140 Cheshire Rd. Galena, OH 43021 What's included: Each ticket reserves a pum