Rainbow Cake SliceRainbow vanilla bean cake. --Colors of the layers may be different depending upon the season! If color is important please call the shop to confirm what is in stock.
$10.25
Strawberry- Cake SliceVanilla sponge cake layered with strawberry filling, typically includes fresh strawberries and is topped with strawberry buttercream.
$10.25
Death by Chocolate- Cake SliceThe name explains it all!!! Chocolate overload!
$10.25
Cookies and Cream- Cake SliceLayers of moist vanilla cake with crushed chocolate cookies, topped with whipped cream frosting.
$10.25
Specialty Desserts and Baskets
Mini Mashup Cookie BasketMini mashup cookies served with our house made buttercream!!! This is 3 of our most popular flavors served with buttercream frosting. You will receive 4 of each flavor in the basket..
$18.50
OLO Brownies
Buckeye BrownieRich brownie topped with creamy peanut butter swirls, chocolate drizzle, and crumbled peanut butter pieces.
$6
Cookies and Cream BrownieRich brownie topped with swirls of cream frosting, crumbled cookies, and a whole cookie for a delightful crunch.
$6
OLO Cupcakes
Mystery Pack Cupcake (12)Assorted cupcakes featuring various toppings including caramel drizzle, chocolate chips, cookie crumbs, cinnamon sticks, and colorful sprinkles. Includes twelve cupcakes with diverse flavors and decorations.
$42
Mystery Pack Cupcake (6)An assortment of six cupcakes featuring various toppings, including sprinkles, a cookie, a carrot decoration, and colorful frosting.
$21
Yesterday's creations 12 count mystery packA 12 count sampling of overstock cupcakes from the previous day. A great way to save a little on our tasty cupcakes. No flavor substitutions are allowed and what you receive will be a mystery until delivered.
$31
Yesterday's Creations 6 count Mystery PackA 6 count sampling of overstock cupcakes from the previous day. A great way to save a little on our tasty cupcakes. No flavor substitutions are allowed and what you receive will be a mystery until delivered.
$15
Strawberry Crunch Cheesecake CupcakeStrawberry cupcake filled with in house cheesecake filling, topped with our whip , strawberry crunch mixture and cheesecake bites!
$3.60
Red Velvet CupcakeRed velvet cupcake topped with cream cheese buttercream and a toasted red velvet crumble!
$3.60
Lemon Blueberry CupcakeLemon cupcake with fresh blueberries baked into the cupcake, topped with freeze dried blueberry buttercream and a fresh blueberry!
$3.60
Buckeye CupcakeChocolate cupcake filled with chocolate ganache, topped with peanut butter buttercream, chocolate ganache and buckeye crumble!
$3.60
Rainbow Explosiongreen and red marble vanilla cupcake filled with a sprinkle explosion, topped with our signature vanilla buttercream, topped with holiday sprinkles and edible glitter.
$3.60
Birthday CupcakeCake batter flavored cupcake, topped with cake batter buttercream and neon quin sprinkles!
$3.60
Creme Brulee CupcakeVanilla cupcake with our house made vanilla custard, topped with cream cheese buttercream and torched sugar!
$3.60
Holy CannoliWho doesn’t love a cannoli! You can now have it in cupcake form. Vanilla cupcake filled with in house Italian cannoli filling topped with vanilla buttercream , mini chocolate chips, powdered sugar and a pizzelle chip!
$3.35
Pineapple Upside Down CupcakeVanilla cupcake with a brown sugar bottom, crushed pineapple layer , a cherry baked into the cupcake. Topped with our house whip and another cherry!
$3.60
Cinnamon Roll Cupcake
$3.60
S'more CupcakeChocolate cupcake filled with chocolate ganache and toasted marshmallow filling. Topped with vanilla buttercream, chocolate ganache, toasted graham cracker crumble and a toasted marshmallow!
$3.60
German Chocolate CupcakeRich chocolate cupcake topped with smooth chocolate frosting and a dollop of caramelized coconut-pecan filling.
$3.60
What's Up Doc CupcakeMoist carrot cupcake topped with creamy vanilla frosting and a small fondant carrot.
$3.75
Dirt CupcakeChocolate cupcake filled with our chocolate mousse , topped with our vanilla whip , Oreo cookie crumble and a gummy worm!
$3.60
Topsy TurtleChocolate cupcake filled with chocolate ganache and house made caramel, topped with caramel buttercream, chocolate ganache, house made caramel and toffee bits!
$3.60
Pumpkin Spice Latte CupcakeMoist pumpkin cupcake topped with creamy white frosting and a decorative pumpkin-shaped candy.
$3.60
Brown Butter Vanilla CupcakeRich vanilla cupcake topped with a swirl of brown butter frosting.
$3.60
Salted Caramel CupcakeSalted caramel cupcake filled with in house caramel, topped with caramel buttercream and caramel drizzle!
$3.60
Cookies and Cream CupcakeVanilla cupcake with Oreo crumbles baked into the cupcake, topped with cookies and cream buttercream!
$3.60
OLO Other Goodies
Buckeyes (6)Rich peanut butter centers enrobed in smooth chocolate, forming six bite-sized confections.
$18
Dot CakeLayers of soft cake with vibrant rainbow sprinkles and a hint of strawberry filling.
$6.50
Mystery Freeze Dried CandyEnjoy our delicious freeze dried candy! Mystery flavor could be ice cream, Skittles, Airheads, Starbursts etc.
$8
Sugar Cookie- smiley face , various colorsSoft sugar cookie topped with blue icing and a cheerful black smiley face design.
$3.60
Sugar Cookie- Creme BrûléeA delicate sugar cookie topped with a layer of caramelized crème brûlée.
$3.60
Buckeye BarPeanut butter fudge topped with chocolate ganache!
$5.75
Mystery Sample Box12 amazing sugar rush Columbus items randomly selected to satisfy your sweet tooth!!!!
$45
Sugar Cookie- SprinkleA soft sugar cookie generously topped with colorful sprinkles, offering a delightful crunch in every bite.
$3.60
Cake Pop- VanillaVanilla cake pop coated in white chocolate and decorated with colorful sprinkles.
$3.40
OLO Mashup Cookies
Campfire S'more Mashup CookieCampfire not required! A sumptuous blend of milk chocolate, dehydrated marshmallows, cinnamon graham crackers and filled with a jumbo marshmallow!
$5.95
The O.G. Mashup CookieThe originator of our mash up cookies! Our signature dough mixed with semi sweet chocolate chips!
$5.95
OH My Buckeye Mashup CookieOH!! Think buckeye in cookie form! Our chocolate dough, mixed with mini peanut butter chips, a whole buckeye in the center, drizzled in chocolate and peanut butter ganache!
$5.95
Peanut Butter Overload Mashup CookieAn explosion of peanut butter in this cookie!! Our signature dough mixed with peanut butter, peanut butter chips , Reese pieces and filled with a naked buckeye in the center!!
$5.95
Brickhouse Mashup CookieA large cookie topped with a chocolate center, drizzled with caramel, and garnished with waffle cone pieces.
$7.80
M&m Mashup CookieOur version of the best m&m cookie! Our signature dough mixed and topped with mini m&m's!
$5.95
The Floor is LavaThe floor is lava! This delicious chocolate cookie is a lava cake in cookie form. Made with our signature chocolate dough, dark chocolate chips, chunks of chocolate cake and filled in the center with our chocolate ganache. Best way to eat it , HOT ! Heat this delicious cookie up for 10-15 seconds in
$5.95
Fat Narwhal Mashup CookieThis cookie is 9.5 oz of deliciousness! Made with our signature mash up cookie dough , this cookie is mixed with sea salt caramel , mini MMS , wavy potato chips, pretzels ,mini chocolate chips and filled with a chocolate covered caramel ball. We then topped it off with caramel , chocolate ganache, s
$7.80
Cookie Confusion Mashup Cookie2 of our very famous mash up doughs, OG and Chocolate , mixed together with vanilla and chocolate chips filled with our brownie chunks!
$5.95
Cookie Monster Mashup Cookie"C is for cookie, that's good enough for me" This massive blue cookie is mixed with cookie crisp cereal and crushed Oreos, filled in the center with a mini chocolate chip cookie and an Oreo!
$5.95
Cookies and Cream Mashup CookieWho doesn't love cookies and cream? This cookie is full of white chocolate chips , crushed up Oreos and even an Oreo baked in the center!
$5.95
Strawberry Cheesequake Mashup CookieThink cheesecake and a strawberry goody bar in a cookie! Mixed with our signature dough, strawberry extract, freeze dried strawberries, mini vanilla chips, strawberry poptarts ,filled in the center with fresh strawberry filling and cheesecake chunks. Topped with vanilla ganache and strawberry crunch
$5.95
Mega Doodle Mashup CookieOur twist on a snickerdoodle! Our signature dough mixed with cinnamon , sugar, cinnamon pop tarts and a buttery sugar center!
$5.95
Over the Rainbow Mashup CookieSomewhere over the rainbow , way up high this cookie is our signature dough, colored to match the rainbow , flavored with cake batter emulsion , cake chunks and topped with edible glitter and sprinkles !
$5.95
Brown Butter Chocolate Pecan Mashup CookieA rich brown butter cookie with chocolate chips and pecan pieces, topped with a sprinkle of sea salt.
$5.95
Cookie Butter Crunch Mashup CookieDrizzled with caramel, this cookie features a crunchy cookie butter topping and crumbles, offering a delightful blend of textures and flavors.
$5.95
90'S KidThis cookie is mashed up with our sugar cookie chunks, cookie MMS , cake chunks , white chocolate chips , neon sprinkles , filled with our rainbow cake and topped with our dunkaroo inspired buttercream !!
$5.95
Chocolate Chip Toffee CrunchStudded with rich chocolate chips and topped with a drizzle of toffee, this cookie offers a satisfying crunch.
$5.95
OLO Macarons
Macaron Variety Pack (6 Pack)Vibrant, crisp macarons with a delicate shell and a smooth, creamy filling in assorted flavors. Six pieces per pack.
$16.50
Orange MacaronDelicate orange macaron with a smooth, creamy filling.
$2.95
Lemon MacaronBright yellow macaron with a zesty lemon filling.
$2.95
Lime MacaronBright green macaron with a smooth, crisp shell and a creamy lime-flavored filling.
$2.95
Macaron Variety Pack (12 Pack)A selection of 12 assorted macarons featuring vibrant colors and a variety of flavors, with delicate almond meringue shells and creamy fillings.
$35
Blueberry MacaronDelicate blueberry macaron with a smooth blueberry-infused filling sandwiched between two crisp, yet tender almond meringue shells.
$2.95
Strawberry MacaronDelicate almond meringue cookie with a creamy strawberry filling.
$2.95
OLO Quick Cake
Strawberry Cheesecake Crunch Quick Cake2 six inch layers of strawberry cake filled with cheesecake filling, iced with our in house whip and covered with strawberry crunch! NOT CUSTOMIZABLE We Do not add Any writing To any of our cakes.
$47
Birthday Cake Quick CakeConfetti cake batter flavored cake with cake batter buttercream! 2 six inch layers serves 10 NOT CUSTOMIZABLE We Do not add Any writing To any of our cakes.
$47
Chocolate Quick CakeChocolate cake with vanilla buttercream and a chocolate ganache drip! NOT CUSTOMIZABLE We Do not add Any writing To any of our cakes.
$47
Red Velvet Quick Cake With Cream Cheese Buttercream2 six inch layers of our delicious red velvet cake iced with our cream cheese buttercream! NOT CUSTOMIZABLE We Do not add Any writing To any of our cakes.
$47
Strawberry Quick Cake with Strawberry Buttercream2 six inch layers of strawberry cake with strawberry buttercream and a white ganache drip! NOT CUSTOMIZABLE We Do not add Any writing To any of our cakes.
$47
Death by Chocolate Quick Cake2 six inch layers of chocolate cake filled with chocolate ganache , chocolate crisp pearls, iced with chocolate buttercream and a chocolate ganache drip! We DO NOT write on any of our Quick Cakes! NOT CUSTOMIZABLE
$49.50
Buckeye Quick Cake2 six inch layers of chocolate cake layers filled with chocolate ganache and buckeye crumble. Peanut butter buttercream, chocolate drip , topped with more buckeye crumble! NOT CUSTOMIZABLE We Do not add Any writing To any of our cakes.
$49.50
Cookies and Cream Quick Cake2 six inch layers of cookies and cream cake layers wrapped with our in house buttercream icing with cookie crumble. Photo may not represent current product. NOT CUSTOMIZABLE We Do not add Any writing To any of our cakes.
$47
Rainbow Vanilla Quick Cake2 six inch layers of swirled rainbow vanilla flavored cake layers, iced with rainbow buttercream and rainbow sprinkles! NOT CUSTOMIZABLE We Do not add Any writing To any of our cakes.