Margherita Monday Special 18"One of our most popular pies for just $15 every Monday! No toppings can be added to this special.
$16
Feed the Family Deal
Feed the Family Deal1 Large 18" One Topping Pizza 12 Garlic Knots 10 Wings 1 Large House or Caesar Salad
$40
Build Your Own Pizza
NY Style Hand-TossedAll Build Your Own pizzas start with our fresh handmade dough, classic sauce, and premium whole-milk buffalo mozzarella. Baked golden off the peel, no screens, no shortcuts, just real New York-style pizza the way it’s supposed to be.
Grandma Style PizzaSame size as our Sicilian, just thinner, crispier, and baked like only Grandma would’ve done it, part baked then pan-finished, and full of flavor. Feeds 3–4 or one person who really misses their Nonni.
$25
Sicilian Style PizzaA neighborhood classic with thick, airy dough and a crispy golden crust. Feeds 3–4… or one local legend who isn’t afraid of a square-cut challenge. Perfect for family nights, leftovers (maybe), and pure New York nostalgia.
$25
Gluten-Free 10" Pizza
$15
NY Style Specialty Pizzas
MeatzaCalling all meat lovers, no veggies in sight. This New York-style favorite is loaded with pepperoni, Italian sausage, crispy bacon, and diced ham over our signature tomato sauce and mozzarella. A hearty, flavor-packed pie that keeps Flagler Beach fueled.
EverythingA little bit of this, a little bit of that… and a whole lot of everything. Loaded with pepperoni, Italian sausage, diced ham, bell peppers, onions, garlic, mushrooms, and black olives over our signature tomato sauce and mozzarella. A neighborhood favorite for those who want it all.
MargheritaOur signature pizza sauce, grandma sauce, creamy fresh mozzarella, and fresh garlic. Finished with basil, parmesan, and olive oil — a Tony’s classic that’s simple and full of flavor.
The 386Where sweet heat meets cheesy perfection. Crispy pepperoni, smoky bacon, and a drizzle of Mike’s Hot Honey over our signature tomato sauce and mozzarella. A spicy-sweet Flagler Beach favorite.
Uncle PaulieOld-school New York flavors: mozzarella, grandma sauce and garlic, topped with olive oil, parmesan, and basil. The perfect mix!
Veggie DelightOur signature tomato sauce and mozzarella topped with fresh spinach, bell peppers, onions, mushrooms, garlic, black olives and diced tomatoes. A garden-fresh favorite that’s simple, colorful, and full of flavor.
Classic WhiteHand-tossed dough topped with creamy mozzarella and seasoned ricotta, with fresh garlic, parmesan, and a drizzle of olive oil.
Fat TonyAll the flavors of a classic lasagna on a crisp New York-style crust. Sliced sausage, crumbled meatball, rich marinara, mozzarella, and creamy ricotta finished with parmesan and parsley. How you doin’? A slice of New York right here in Flagler Beach.
Buffalo ChickenCrispy breaded chicken layered on bold Buffalo sauce and premium buffalo-milk mozzarella, topped with parmesan, fresh parsley, and a smooth drizzle of ranch dressing.
Flagler MauiIt’s sweet, salty, and a little controversial... just like your cousin who moved to Flagler Beach and started surfing. Our signature tomato sauce, melted mozzarella, sweet pineapple tidbits, and diced ham.
Spicy CharlieSavory, spicy, and full of attitude, just like Charlie. This New York-style favorite brings the heat with pepperoni, Italian sausage, caramelized onions, and crushed red pepper over our signature tomato sauce and mozzarella. A bold, neighborhood favorite.
Happy VeganNo dairy in sight, just pure, plant-powered flavor. This pie starts with our signature tomato sauce and is topped with fresh spinach, diced tomatoes, peppers, mushrooms, onions, black olives and fresh garlic. Finished with premium vegan cheese that melts just right. It’s bright, bold, and 100% vegan
Grandma Pizzas
Uncle Paulie - Grandmas CrustOld-school New York flavors: mozzarella, grandma sauce, fresh mozzarella, and garlic, topped with olive oil, parmesan, and basil. The perfect mix!
$30
The 386 - Grandmas CrustWhere sweet heat meets cheesy perfection. Crispy pepperoni, smoky bacon, and a drizzle of Mike’s Hot Honey over our signature tomato sauce and mozzarella. A spicy-sweet Flagler Beach favorite.
$31
Buffalo Chicken - Grandmas CrustCrispy breaded chicken layered on bold Buffalo sauce and premium buffalo-milk mozzarella, topped with parmesan, fresh parsley, and a smooth drizzle of ranch dressing.
$31
The Brooklyn BBQ - Grandmas CrustPremium mozzarella layered with bacon, crispy breaded chicken, and sliced onions, finished with a balanced barbecue–ranch drizzle, parmesan, and fresh parsley for the perfect smoky-sweet bite.
$31
Craft Pizzas
The Golden Goat - Large 18"Roasted corn, crisp bacon, creamy goat cheese and slow-caramelized onions over premium mozzarella, finished with a touch of hot honey.
$32
The Golden Goat - Grandmas Crust
$34
Pop's Pesto Roni - Large 18"A creamy basil pesto base, layered with mozzarella, pepperoni and fresh garlic. Finished with parmesan, fresh parsley and a hot honey drizzle!
$31
Pop's Pesto Roni - Grandmas CrustA creamy basil pesto base, layered with mozzarella, pepperoni and fresh garlic. Finished with parmesan, fresh parsley and a hot honey drizzle!
$33
THE BIG CHEESE - Large 18'A five-cheese white pizza with premium mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, ricotta, feta and parmesan, finished with fresh parsley.
$30
THE BIG CHEESE - Grandmas CrustA five-cheese white pizza with premium mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, ricotta, feta and parmesan, finished with fresh parsley.
$32
Sweet Heat - Large 18"Premium mozzarella topped with creamy ranch, breaded chicken and smoky bacon, finished with parmesan, parsley and a drizzle of hot honey for the perfect sweet heat in every bite!
$32
Sweet Heat - Grandmas CrustPremium mozzarella topped with creamy ranch, breaded chicken and smoky bacon, finished with parmesan, parsley and a drizzle of hot honey for the perfect sweet heat in every bite!
$34
Large Salads
House Salad LargeRomaine lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, cucumbers, bell peppers, and house made croutons.
$10
Greek SaladRomaine lettuce, ham, feta cheese, pepperoncini, kalamata olives, onions, sliced tomatoes, and cucumber served with our greek dressing.
$14
Caesar Salad LargeRomaine lettuce tossed with caesar dressing, served with parmesan cheese and house made croutons.
$10
Tony's Antipasto SaladRomaine lettuce topped with fresh sliced salami, pepperoni, ham, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, onions, sliced tomatoes, served with our house dressing.
$15
Buffalo Chicken SaladRomaine lettuce, sliced tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, crumbled feta, and crispy chicken tossed in our signature buffalo sauce.
$15
Strawberry FieldsRomaine & spinach mix, fresh cut strawberries, red onions, feta cheese, candied pecans topped with a balsamic reduction. Served with balsamic dressing!
$14
Small Salads
House Salad SmallRomaine lettuce, sliced tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, bell peppers, and house made croutons.
$5
Caesar Salad SmallRomaine lettuce tossed with caesar dressing, served with parmesan cheese and house made croutons.
$5
Shareables
Jumbo WingsCrispy on the outside, juicy on the inside. Our jumbo wings are tossed in your choice of sauce, served with a side of blue cheese or ranch.
$10
Garlic Knots Half DozenPillowy, and straight outta the oven! Our fresh dough, hand-rolled and baked to golden perfection. Tossed in olive oil, garlic, parsley, and parmesan, served hot with a side of marinara.
$7
Garlic Knots DozenPillowy, and straight outta the oven! Our fresh dough, hand-rolled and baked to golden perfection. Tossed in olive oil, garlic, parsley, and parmesan, served hot with a side of marinara.
$11
Garlic Knots (2)Pillowy, and straight outta the oven! Our fresh dough, hand-rolled and baked to golden perfection. Tossed in olive oil, garlic, parsley, and parmesan, served hot with a side of marinara.
$2.50
Chicken TendersFive crispy, golden-brown chicken tenders fried to perfection. Served with a side of honey mustard.
$12
Fried PicklesHand-breaded pickle chip fried until perfectly crisp. Topped with grated Parmesan and parsley, and served with a side of ranch.
$10
Seasoned FriesCrispy crinkle cut fries tossed in garlic powder, black pepper, and a dash of salt!
$6
Parmesan PoppersGolden, bite-sized fried dough tossed in a buttery garlic Parmesan sauce, topped with grated Parmesan and a sprinkle of parsley. Served hot with a side of signature marinara sauce.
$10
Mozzarella SticksCrispy on the outside, cheesy on the inside. Six golden-brown mozzarella sticks, sprinkled with Parmesan and parsley, served with a side of our signature marinara.
$9.50
Garlic BreadHand-cut sub roll, brushed with garlic butter, toasted to perfection, and topped with parmesan and parsley. Served with a side of warm marinara!
$7
SoupOur Pasta Fagioli Soup is a warm hug in a bowl—ditalini pasta, tender beans, meatball, savory tomato broth, and a sprinkle of parmesan and parsley to finish!
$5
Side of MeatballsTastes like Noni's meatballs! Three meatballs, cut in half and smothered in our signature marinara, baked with premium mozzarella, and finished with parmesan and fresh parsley.
$9.50
Strombolis, Calzones & Rolls
StromboliItalian sausage, pepperoni, onions, green peppers, and mozzarella all baked inside our fresh dough. Brushed with olive oil, parmesan, and parsley, and served with a side of marinara. A golden, hearty roll of pure Tony’s flavor.
$15
Party StromboliItalian sausage, pepperoni, onions, green peppers, and mozzarella all baked inside our fresh dough. Brushed with olive oil, parmesan, and parsley, and served with a side of marinara. A golden, hearty roll of pure Tony’s flavor.
$29
CalzoneSeasoned ricotta and mozzarella baked inside our fresh dough, brushed with olive oil, parmesan, and parsley. Served hot and golden, with marinara on the side, folded perfection, Tony’s style.
$14
Party CalzoneSeasoned ricotta and mozzarella baked inside our fresh dough, brushed with olive oil, parmesan, and parsley. Served hot and golden, with marinara on the side, folded perfection, Tony’s style.
$28
Meat CalzoneSeasoned ricotta, mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage, crispy bacon, diced ham baked inside our fresh dough, brushed with olive oil, parmesan, and parsley. Served hot and golden, with marinara on the side, folded perfection, Tony’s style.
$19
Party Meat CalzoneSeasoned ricotta, mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage, crispy bacon, diced ham baked inside our fresh dough, brushed with olive oil, parmesan, and parsley. Served hot and golden, with marinara on the side, folded perfection, Tony’s style.
$31
Veggie CalzoneSeasoned ricotta, mozzarella, fresh spinach, bell peppers, onions, mushrooms, garlic and diced tomatoes baked inside our fresh dough, brushed with olive oil, parmesan, and parsley. Served hot and golden, with marinara on the side, folded perfection, Tony’s style.
$18
Party Veggie CalzoneSeasoned ricotta, mozzarella, fresh spinach, bell peppers, onions, mushrooms, garlic and diced tomatoes baked inside our fresh dough, brushed with olive oil, parmesan, and parsley. Served hot and golden, with marinara on the side, folded perfection, Tony’s style.
$30
Cheese RollMozzarella wrapped in our fresh dough, brushed with olive oil, parmesan, and parsley, then baked golden. Served with marinara on the side. Add your favorite toppings to make it your own.
$11.50
Party Cheese RollMozzarella wrapped in our fresh dough, brushed with olive oil, parmesan, and parsley, then baked golden. Served with marinara on the side. Add your favorite toppings to make it your own.
$21
Chicken RollBreaded chicken and mozzarella wrapped in our fresh dough, brushed with olive oil, parmesan, and parsley, then baked golden. Served with marinara on the side. Spice it up Buffalo or BBQ style for just $2 more.
$14
Party Chicken RollBreaded chicken and mozzarella wrapped in our fresh dough, brushed with olive oil, parmesan, and parsley, then baked golden. Served with marinara on the side. Spice it up Buffalo or BBQ style for just $2 more.
$28
Eggplant Roll(atini)Breaded eggplant cutlets stuffed with seasoned ricotta, mozzarella, and sweet tomato sauce, then baked and brushed with olive oil, parmesan, and parsley. Served with a side of marinara, a golden, cheesy twist on a classic Italian favorite.
$14
Party Eggplant Roll(atini)Breaded eggplant cutlets stuffed with seasoned ricotta, mozzarella, and sweet tomato sauce, then baked and brushed with olive oil, parmesan, and parsley. Served with a side of marinara, a golden, cheesy twist on a classic Italian favorite.
$28
386 PinwheelsFour fresh-baked pinwheels stuffed with mozzarella, pepperoni, and bacon, brushed with olive oil, parmesan, and parsley, then finished with a drizzle of Mike’s Hot Honey. Sweet, salty, and straight-up addictive. A Tony’s favorite!
$16
Spinach Feta PinwheelsFour fresh-baked pinwheels stuffed with spinach, feta, garlic, mozzarella, and ricotta cheese, brushed with olive oil, parmesan, and parsley. You're not going to want to share these!
$16
Classic Subs
Meatball Parm SubOur popular meatballs smothered in marinara and mozzarella cheese, toasted to perfection in our homemade sub rolls.
$13.50
Eggplant Parm SubBreaded eggplant cutlets smothered in marinara and mozzarella cheese, toasted to perfection in our homemade sub rolls.
$13.50
Chicken Parm SubBreaded chicken cutlets smothered in marinara and mozzarella cheese, toasted to perfection in our homemade sub rolls.
$13.50
Buffalo Tender SubSliced tenders tossed in our buffalo sauce toasted with mozzarella & served with ranch.
$13.50
Sausage, Peppers & Onion SubMild Italian sausage, green peppers, and caramelized onions smothered in marinara and mozzarella cheese. Toasted to perfection in our homemade sub rolls.
$13.50
Baked Pasta Dinners
Spaghetti & Meatball DinnerThree of our signature meatballs served over a generous portion of spaghetti, covered in marinara, and baked to perfection with melted mozzarella. Simple, hearty, and straight from Tony’s kitchen.
$18.50
Baked Ziti DinnerA perfect blend of seasoned ricotta and our rich marinara sauce tossed with penne pasta, then baked to perfection with melted mozzarella. A timeless classic. Add meatballs if you’d like!
$17.50
Meat Lasagna DinnerWhat do you call lasagna stacked on top of lasagna? Lasagna! Layers of seasoned ricotta, our signature meatballs, and rich tomato sauce, all topped with marinara and baked with melted mozzarella. Classic comfort, Tony’s way!
$17.50
Chicken Parmesan DinnerTwo crispy chicken cutlets served over a generous portion of spaghetti, covered in marinara, and baked to perfection with melted mozzarella. How you doin’?
$18.50
Eggplant Parmesan DinnerBreaded eggplant cutlets served over a generous portion of spaghetti, covered in marinara, and baked to perfection with melted mozzarella. A veggie classic!
$18.50
Large Pasta Marinara
$10.50
Small Pasta Marinara
$7.50
Desserts
Dessert Special
$6.50
Zeppolis FullOur homemade dough, fried, served warm and tossed in powdered sugar.
$9
Zeppolis HalfOur homemade dough, fried, served warm and tossed in powdered sugar.
$6
CannoliTraditional cannoli shell filled with sweet cream, mini chocolate chips and garnished with powdered sugar.
$4
Chocolate CannoliChocolate dipped cannoli shell filled with sweet cream, mini chocolate chips and garnished with powdered sugar.
$5
New York Style CheesecakeSlice of delicious New York style cheesecake.
$6
Nutella Stuffed Pizza
$15
Sauces
Ranch (2oz)
$0.75
Blue Cheese (2oz)
$0.75
Hot Honey (2oz)
$1.50
Marinara Sauce (3.25oz)
$0.75
Marinara Sauce (Pint)
$6
Honey Mustard (2oz)
$0.75
House Dressing (2oz)
$0.75
Sweet Baby Rays BBQ (2oz)
$0.75
Garlic Butter (2oz)
$1
Buffalo Sauce (2oz)
$0.75
Hot Sauce (2oz)
$0.75
Extra Dressing
$0.50
Teriyaki (2oz)
$0.75
Mango Habanero (2oz)
$0.75
Beverages
Bottled Water
$2.50
San Pellegrino 16.9oz
$3.50
Bambino
Kids Spaghetti & Meatball DinnerA comfort bowl built for little ones, warm spaghetti, a tender meatball cut in half, our slow-simmered marinara, and a touch of parmesan on top.
$9
Kids Chicken Parmesan DinnerA crispy chicken cutlet set on a bed of spaghetti, finished with marinara and parmesan. All the flavors of classic chicken parm, just kid-sized.
$9
Kids Penne with Oil & ParmesanKid-sized penne tossed in extra virgin olive oil and parmesan cheese.
$7
Kids Chicken Tenders & FriesTwo crispy chicken tenders with a side of fries. Simple, tasty, and perfect for kids (and anyone young at heart)!