Oatmeal Raisin CookiesPacked with flavor - you either love them or gotta have more!
$25
SnickerdoodlesJust what a snickerdoodle should be - fluffy and thick!
$20
Lemon Sugar CookiesThese are a crowd-pleaser year-round with the fail-safe combo of sugar cookies and lemon!
$25
S'mores CookiesGraham cracker, marshmallow, chocolate all wrapped into a delicious cookie! June cookie of the month!
$23
Jammy DodgersLemon poppy seed shortbread cookie with lemon buttercream and lemon curd - just enough sweet and tart in this mouthwatering cookie! Price is for 1 dozen (12).
$3.50
M&M Cookies
$20
Molasses CookiesSoft and thick molasses cookies
$25
The Big Game Cookie Decorating ClassSaturday, January 25 @ 2:30 p.m. located at Sifted & Sweet Baking Co, 800 Holiday Drive Suite 176, Moorhead. We’ll be ramping up excitement for the BIG GAME with this approximate 1.5-hour cookie decorating class! Don’t be left out on the huddle with this fun 6-cookie, 4-icing class! Once you have pu
$45
Cookie PlatesBuild your own variety cookie plate!
$45
Buttercream Sugar CookiesVanilla buttercream with vanilla cookies. Enjoy a soft bite cookie, similar to Lofthouse (but better!).
$24
Lemon Bar CookieApril Cookie of the Month! A lemon bar in cookie form. Soft and tender, this cookie is made with cream cheese and butter with a touch of almond extract. In the center sits flavorful lemon curd. Divine and a must have! Single cookies in store are $4. Buy 1/2 dozen and 1 dozen at discounted prices! Or
$22
Strawberry Poptart CookieMAY COOKIE OF THE MONTH Filled with real strawberries, and a cookie made from real ingredients including crushed shortbread cookies. It's a match made in homemade heaven.
$28
DIY Father's Day Cookie Kit1 DIY KIT: 6 cookies, 4 colors, sprinkles, and a Cookie Playlist (step-by-step directions) **colors may vary in depth of color and shades. Pick up June 13 or June 14.
$20
Monster CookieClassic Monster Cookies with major peanut butter flavor! These cookies are FULL of peanut butter and chocolate flavor!
$26
Peanut Butter CookiesClassic peanut butter cookies. Thick and soft, eat them with a glass of milk.
Strawberry Shortcake Cookie (CotM)Cookie of the Month - JULY! Trust us when we say you are going to want to try these for yourself. Fresh strawberries, shortcake crumble in and out... in summary, they're the perfect summer cookie!
$23
Chocolate Chip CookiesSoft and flavorful chocolate chip. This one is a crowd pleaser!
$25
MacaronsClassic macarons. Orders are one flavor per dozen. For seasonal flavors, find "Seasonal Macarons" in the menu (if available).
$30
Menu
Apple PieClassic apple pie! Thanksgiving apple pies will have a full top crust. Choose between regular and gluten free.
$24
Pie
$5
Pi Day PiesChoose your pie for PI DAY 3.14.26! Reserve your full pie now, or come in for a $3.14 slice of pie on Saturday! Please note that these pies will be available for PICKUP on Saturday, March 14 from 8 a.m. to 3 p.m.
$13
Carrot CakeOur signature carrot cake, classically decorated with cream cheese icing and carrots. 5" serves up to 5. 6" serves up to 12. Pickup for Easter available until Saturday, April 4 @ 3 p.m.
$25
Easter Name Sugar CookieA great addition to an Easter basket or even for employees! Customize an Easter bunny cookie with a name and color of name. Easter pickup through Saturday, April 19, until 2 p.m.
$6
Thanksgiving Pie Decorated Sugar CookiesThanksgiving style sugar cookies in multiple options! ***2025 update: Center cookie will say "Happy Thanksgiving"**** Cookies are flavored with vanilla and almond. 8 cookies decorated like a full pumpkin pie. One center cookie with with "Happy Thanksgiving"
$32
Cozy Sampler (Small)Serves 6-8, 18-22 pieces. Perfect for: Hostess gifts, teacher gifts, small families, office thank-yous. What it includes: Decorated sugar cookies, assorted cookie and Christmas cookie classics, hot cocoa truffles, assorted macarons, and choose among peanut butter balls, peanut brittle, and puppy cho
$39
Santa Cookie SetSanta! This guy is approximately 11.5 inches tall by 10 inches at his widest point. Comes with 9 cookies, but can serve up to 15, more if larger cookies are cut smaller.
$28
DIY Santa Cookie Kit6 cookies (Santa's boot, bag, sleigh, coat, hat, and pants) 4 colors (red, black, white, gold) All kits come with a photo to use as an optional guide for decorating. **colors may vary in depth of color and shades.
$18
Pecan PieClassic pecan pie, full of flavor! This is for PREORDER only. Limited availability for walk-in purchases.
$25.60
Pumpkin PieClassic pumpkin pie filled with mouth watering flavor! This is PREORDER only. Limited quantities will be kept in stock for walk-in purchases.
$24
Tea
$2
Citrus Juicer
$15
Hot Cocoa
$3.50
Peanut Brittle10 oz of buttery, nutty candy. Available as preorder only for pickup on 12/23 or find it in-store beginning in December 5.
$9
Slurper with straw
$27
Tea retail
$10
Mug retail
$15
Olive Oil
$27
Parfaits
$7
Spoon rest
$12
Cake Cup
$6
Coke Zero Bottle
$2.50
Diet Coke Bottle
$2.50
Mello Yello
$2.50
Barq’s
$2.50
Chocolate chip Cookie
$4
Case Cake
$28
Slice cake
$4.50
ComboSoup combined with choice of pasty or sandwich. Make it a meal by adding a cookie and a drink for $4
$17
Mustikkapirrakka
$5
Kevin’s Signs
$12
Bagel Egg Sausage
$6.50
Sandwiches
$8
Bag of Chips
$2.25
Pulla Rolls
$3
Muffins/Cupcakes
$3.75
Cheesecake Bar
$4.75
Easter Decorated CookiesAdd some color to your weekend! Two options: simple, but cute bunny cookies or a mix set with carrot bags, bunny with a carrot, and bunnies!
$35
Teacher AppreciationSend a thoughtful gift to a teacher in your life! Preorders must be sent in by Wednesday at 9 a.m. Otherwise, limited quantities available in store.
$15
Americano
$4.50
Lemonade
$4
Add egg
$2
"Gilmore Girls" Cookie Decorating ClassWhere you lead, we will follow… straight to Stars Hollow. We’re ushering in fall the Stars Hollow way on Saturday, September 19 at 2:30 p.m. Grab your coffee-loving, fast-talking bestie and join us for an afternoon of sugar cookies, royal icing, and enough Gilmore Girls references to make Kirk consi
$49
Thanksgiving DIY Cookie KitA six cookie Thanksgiving themed DIY kit! Preorder for Tuesday, November 25 and 26th pickup. All kits will be ready on the 25th, but pickup can be either the 25th or 26th. Kits come with six cookies, a "playlist" to help you through the steps, and four icing colors!
$20
Cranberry Crumble Pie BarsShortbread crust and top with slightly tart, slightly sweet cranberry filling and drizzled with an orange glaze - perfect for cranberry lovers! Delicious for all! One order comes with 12 bars, which is equal to a 9x13 pan. PREORDER only for November 26th. This item will not be available for walk-in
$22.40
DIY Love Monsters Cookie Kit3 cookies, 4 colors, and a Cookie Playlist to help with the steps of the cookie! Of course, the steps are completely optional and you can decorate them however your please! All kits come with a photo and Cookie Playlist to use as an optional guide for decorating. **colors may vary in depth of color
$18
"Haunted Hallows" Cookie Decorating EVENING ClassDouble, double, icing trouble… Spooky Season is calling. 👻 Join us for Haunted Hallows, a delightfully spooky cookie decorating class filled with ghosts, potions, spell books, and just enough witchcraft to make your royal icing behave. Grab your favorite ghoul and settle in for an afternoon of suga
$49
Apple Crisp CheesecakeA hybrid dessert of apple crisp and cheesecake with apple crisp in the center as well as heaps on top! Buy in 6" (feeds up to 8) cakes or 9" (feeds up to 15) cakes. Crisp contains almond flour.
$29.60
Easter BRUNCH BoxRegular Brunch Box (12 items) 3 raspberry scones3 bacon cheddar scones3 lemon poppyseed muffins3 mini cinnamon rolls Large Brunch Box (18 Items) Items 4 raspberry scones4 bacon cheddar scones4 lemon poppyseed muffins4 mini cinnamon rolls2 fruit cups (or yogurt parfaits with house-made granola)
$42
Cookie of the Month - White Chocolate PistachioA thick, Levain-style cookie loaded with pistachios and white chocolate chips. Crisp on the outside, soft in the center, and finished with flaky salt. Order online for 1 dozen or more. Please give us at least 2 days notice for more than 3 dozen. See us in store for a quick fix!
$26
November Afternoon TeaAn elegant autumn tea service with thoughtfully curated menu items to celebrate the flavors of the season! Reservations can be made anywhere from 1 - 8 people per table, and available reservations are limited per hour. Menu Includes: Course 1 - Savory Roast beef & Horseradish cream tea sandwich Ched
$50
"Friendsgiving" Cookie Decorating ClassCould this class BE any more Thanksgiving? 🦃 Grab your favorite friend and join us for a Friends-inspired Thanksgiving cookie decorating class celebrating Turkey Day with a little sugar, a little royal icing, and absolutely no beef in the trifle. Settle in for an afternoon of cookie decorating insp
$49
Happy Birthday Decorated CookiesOrder this Happy Birthday cookie set, customize your colors/name/age, and make someone's (or your) day!
$41
"Lemonade Stand" Cookie Decorating ClassJoin us on Thursday, August 27 @ 6 p.m. for a sweet farewell to summer cookie decorating class! Included in your ticket price is a glass of our house lemonade! Interested in learning more about decorated sugar cookies?! Sifted & Sweet Baking Co is here to help! In this 1.5 - 2 hour class, we'll deco
$49
Easter Weekend Sweets BoxThe Easter Weekend Sweets Box is a limited-edition collection of 10 special spring desserts. Each box includes an elegant assortment of 10 items, 2 of each listed below: 2 carrot cake cupcakes2 lemon tarts2 mini strawberry cheese cake2 decorated Easter sugar cookies2 bakery favorite cookies: chocola
$50
Mother's Day Afternoon Tea ServiceCelebrate all moms with an elegant afternoon tea experience featuring a curated three-course menu of savory bites, fresh scones, and refined desserts — perfect for all ages. Menu Includes: Savory Course • Strawberry Chicken Salad Tea Sandwiches • Herbed Gruyere Quiche • Curry Avocado Egg Salad Phyll
$40
Back to School Decorated CookiesChoose your BACK TO SCHOOL decorated cookie(s)! Please allow THREE business days before pickup. Labubu - multiple colors and designs! "Hello [insert grade]" Teacher Name with pencil and apple Full 6 cookie back to school set.
$7
Take 'n Bake Cinnamon/Caramel RollsTake and bake caramel or cinnamon rolls: simply proof, bake, and top with your choice of cinnamon roll frosting or caramel. Currently on PREORDER for Easter weekend. 1 dozen rolls can be split between caramel and cinnamon. Select both cinnamon and caramel. Not available to split for 1/2 dozen. If se
$18
Cookie KITDecorate your own! Comes with 4 colors, 6 cookies! Pickup is Thursday, July 3 only!
$24
Holiday Gathering (Medium)Serves 12 - 15, 35-40 pieces Perfect for: family gatherings, staff break rooms, neighbors, holiday parties. What it includes: Decorated sugar cookies, assorted cookie and Christmas cookie classics, hot cocoa truffles, assorted macarons, and choose among peanut butter balls, peanut brittle, and puppy
$60
"Haunted Hallows" Cookie Decorating ClassDouble, double, icing trouble… Spooky Season is calling. 👻 Join us for Haunted Hallows, a delightfully spooky cookie decorating class filled with ghosts, potions, spell books, and just enough witchcraft to make your royal icing behave. Grab your favorite ghoul and settle in for an afternoon of suga
$49
Christmas Party (Large)Serves 20 - 24, 55-65 pieces Perfect for: holiday open houses, corporate gifting, large family gatherings, Santa events. What it includes: Decorated sugar cookies, assorted cookie and Christmas cookie classics, hot cocoa truffles, assorted macarons, and choose among peanut butter balls, peanut britt
$89
RollsOrder cinnamon or caramel rolls! We make them fresh every day, and do our best to have your rolls out of the oven within a half hour from pickup!. Cinnamon rolls have cream cheese frosting. Caramel rolls are covered with our house made caramel. Please allow at least 24 hours for pick up. We will con
$32
Gingerbread Name CookieCustomize a gingerbread person cookie for your kids, coworkers, friends, and/or family! Please allow three business days (Tues-Sat) for fulfillment.
$7
Desserts
Apple CrispThe best apple crisp you'll ever have. Don't let the gluten free get ya. You will never know the difference. One 8" pan. *Contains almond flour
$6
Puppy ChowChocolately, peanut buttery cereal treat. 12 oz. Not intended for animal consumption. Available as a preorder for pickup on Tuesday, December 23 or find it in store starting December 2.
$12
Breakfast and Bars
Burrito - Breakfast
$7
Cinnamon or Caramel RollsCinnamon rolls, literally the best cinnamon rolls any of us have ever had. Soft, fluffy, gooey with cream cheese frosting and a caramelized bottom almost like a caramel roll. They are absolutely decadent.