Afternoon Break TrayOur most popular goodies are artfully arranged on a tray and is ready to serve! Each contains Chocolate Chunk, Snickerdoodle, M&M, Oatmeal Raisin, Lemon bars, Walnut Brownies and Seasonal Sugar Cookies. Individual wrapping not available
$44
Birthday Cookie Tray1 day lead time - A variety of sweet treats! This delightful preset tray includes three types of decorated cookies and three Oven Fresh flavors (Chocolate Chunk, Snickerdoodle, and Confetti).
$65
Trays of Oven Fresh CookiesOur small size (one ounce each) Oven Fresh Cookies are the perfect size for serving guests at any social function. Presented on a tray and ready to serve. Choose up to four flavors. If you choose "ASSORTED", the flavors will be Chocolate Chunk, Snickerdoodle, M&M and Oatmeal Raisin Individual wrappi
$65
Cookie Cakes
Classic Cookie Cake (white icing)ONLINE COOKIE CAKES ARE WHITE ICING ONLY! Order by 2pm for same day pick-up. -12" serves 12-16 people -14" serves 18-22 people -16" serves 24-35 people If you need other cookie flavors, color icing or custom designs, there is a two day lead time! Go to MICHAELSCOOKIEJAR.COM/COOKIECAKE or Call our st
$36
Halloween Cookie Cake1 day lead time - Be the talk of the party with these scary good cakes! Choose from three sizes! 12" serves 12-16 people14" serves 18-22 people16" serves 24-35 people
$46
Oven Fresh Cookies
Cookie Care Package (colors vary)For local delivery or pick up. What is more comforting than a dozen freshly baked cookies! Each dozen includes one of the "themed" decorated cookies (colors will vary!). Choose up to four cookie flavors. Individual wrapping available for additional fee.
$36.50
Sugar Free Chocolate Chunk - 2pkIndividually packaged with ingredient sticker
$7
Share Pack (6 cookies)Choose up to six delicious Oven Fresh flavors. Please note, if we are out of one of your flavors, we may substitute more of your other flavors.
$16
Fun Pack (12 cookies)For local pick up or delivery. Choose up to six delicious Oven Fresh flavors. Please note, if we are out of one of your flavors, we may substitute more of your other flavors.
$31
Snack Pack (4 cookies)Choose up to four delicious Oven Fresh flavors. Please note, if we are out of one of your flavors, we may substitute more of your other flavors.
$12
Gluten Friendly Chocolate Chunk - 2pkOur delicious gluten friendly Chocolate Chunk Cookie is free of gluten, but is made in a kitchen where gluten in present. It comes individually wrapped with an ingredient label.
$7
The HTX CookieA sweet collaboration between Michael's Cookie Jar and Mostly Chocolate! The HTX is a generous 3 oz cookie made with brown butter, three types of dark chocolate and Mostly Chocolate's house-made pecan toffee. This complex cookie is slightly crunchy with notes of caramel, coffee and molasses. With a
$4.25
Flavor of the Month! (4 pk)Every month we offer you a new and exciting flavor to try out for a limited time! Every one is unique and a truly special chef's creation. Give it a try before they go away!
$12
Celebration Pack (2 DZ)For local pick up or delivery. Choose up to six delicious Oven Fresh flavors. Please note, if we are out of one of your flavors, we may substitute more of your other flavors.
$61
Skinni Cookies (pack of 4)We love our hearty Chocolate Chunk cookies, but sometimes "less is more" which couldn't be more true for our new Skinni Cookies. At just 100 calories each, these thin, crispy delights are packed full of flavor and satisfaction! And, yes, still made with real butter, sugar and natural flavors
$4.75
Twosies Oven Fresh - 2 pkJust like the name says! Choose two cookies from our amazing daily selection! If we're out of stock of one flavor, we'll sub it with a duplicate of your second flavor.
$6
Vegan Chocolate Chunk - 2pkOur vegan cookies are made with Earth Balance margarine and no dairy products. So delicious, you won't even know it's dairy-free. Individually packaged with ingredient sticker.
$7
Oven Fresh (OVF)
Chef's Choice Oven Fresh Variety Box (preset flavors)Great value! This box is a PRESET assortment of our most popular flavors. Flavors may vary from photo. Individual wrapping available for additional fee.
$29
Pumpkin Spice Latte CookieSeptember is here and that means our Deluxe Oven Fresh Special is the "Pumpkin Spice Latte Cookie!" A vanilla cookie stuffed with a pumpkin filling and topped with a toasted coffee meringue. A delicious start to the Fall season!
$4.75
Halloween Cookie TrayNo need to go trick or treating for these sweet treats! This delightful preset tray includes 18 decorated cookies and 18 of our oven fresh cookies (Chocolate Chunk and Confetti)
$65
Decorated Cookies
Birthday CookiesOur brightly colored birthday cookies are a cheerful way to celebrate the special occasion! Each cookie comes individually wrapped. Colors vary!
$5.50
Good VibesNothing makes a day brighter than our smiley face cookies or peace signs. Colors vary. Cookies are 3.5" and come individually wrapped
$3.25
Fall Cookie DesignsOur Fall decorated cookies are 4" tall and come individually wrapped!
$5.50
Astros CookiesCheer on our hometown team with these festive cookies! Cookies are 4" tall and come individually wrapped!
$5.50
Beyond Cookies
Dessert BarsClassic flavors that really satisfy! Our brownies are made with two types of imported French chocolate and our lemon bar contain only real lemon juice! Choose up to two flavors per dozen. Presented in a bakery box. If you'd like the bars cut in half to make "bite-sized" portions, please let us know
$8
The Dubai DelightThe Dubai Delight is two pistachio shortbreads (one with chocolate) sandwiching a delicious milk chocolate ganache and pistachio/kataifi filling. This is a sweet collaboration with our friends at Mostly Chocolate who make the pistachio filling from roasted Turkish pistachios
$5.25
Alfajores (2 pk)A classic South American treat that has been a "best kept secret" at MCJ for years! Everything from the crumbly shortbread cookie to the luscious dulce de leche is made in-house. A perfect treat with your afternoon coffee! (the edge of the pastry is rolled in desiccated coconut)
$5.50
Banana BreadPerfectly ripened bananas and pecans make this sweet bread a classic favorite! Weighing in at 6 ounces per slice it could be the best breakfast or afternoon treat you've ever had! (Individually wrapped)
$4.25
Menu
Halloween DIYThe "Deluxe" kit has 8 large (4") cut-outs in the shape of pumpkins and ghosts. Comes with icing, sprinkles. You only need to bring your imagination!!
$25
Halloween Simple Gift BagThree sweet treats tied up with a hand-tied bow!
$9.50
Halloween Deluxe Iced CookiesBring your trick or treat baskets over for our spook-tastic cookies! Individually packaged
$5.95
Halloween Fancy SleevesSix spooky decorated shortbread cookies wrapped up with a bow!
$17.50
Halloween Classroom PackFeeding a crowd! This box has 12 sugar pumpkins& 12 simple iced ghosts ! Cookies are 3" in size and individually packaged.
$48
Treats that Ship
Chef's Choice Oven Fresh Variety Box (preset flavors) - SHIPPINGGreat value! This box is a PRESET assortment of our most popular flavors. Flavors may vary from photo.
$34.50
Cookie Care Package (colors vary) - SHIPPINGWhat is more comforting than a dozen freshly baked cookies! Each dozen includes one of the "themed" decorated cookies. Choose up to two cookie flavors.
$44
Seasonal
Candy Corn Shortbread (2pk)
$3.75
Gift Ideas
Halloween Fancy Pack16 cookies in 4 designs make up this darling bow-ted box! Cookies are cello-wrapped in packs of two. Cookie flavors include: pumpkin shaped sugar cookiesghost iced cookiespumpkin shaped gingerbread cookiescandy-corn shortbread swirl