Skip to content
Spoonini
what to order
Papa Jimmy's Pizzeria menu · Madison | Spoonini
Madison
Papa Jimmy's Pizzeria
Papa Jimmy's Pizzeria
· $
Directions
Call
Website
Menu
Specialty Pizzas
Papa's Pizza
Pam's Style Pizza
Calzones
Gluten Free
Jimmy's Munchies
Pasta
Subs
Salads
Beverages
Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream
Ice Cream
Sundaes
PJ's Lunch Deals
Subs on the Move
Specialty Pizzas
Bacon Cheeseburger
Ranch sauce, topped with ground beef, bacon, mozzarella & cheddar, lettuce, tomato, onion & pickles
$8.29
Taco
Refried beans & taco sauce, ground beef, mozzarella & cheddar, lettuce, tomato & tortilla chips
$8.29
Bellybuster
Pizza sauce, pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushroom, onion, green pepper, black olives & mozzarella
$8.29
Vegetarian
Pizza sauce, mushroom, onion, green pepper, black olive, tomato & mozzarella
$7.99
Gutbuster
Pizza sauce, mushroom, onion, green pepper, Italian sausage & mozzarella
$7.99
Mac & Cheese
Garlic butter & cheddar cheese sauce, mac & cheese, mozzarella & cheddar, parmesan & black pepper
$7.99
Chicken Rancher
Ranch sauce, mushroom, onion, tomato, bacon, diced chicken, mozzarella & cheddar
$8.29
Hawaiian
Pizza sauce, Canadian bacon, pineapple, tomato & mozzarella
$7.99
Bucky Special
Pizza sauce, extra mushroom, Italian sausage, mozzarella & extra cheddar
$7.99
Spinach Delight
Garlic butter sauce, garlic, spinach, tomato, diced chicken, mozzarella, cheddar and oregano
$7.99
BBQ Chicken
Sweet BBQ sauce, mushroom, onion, diced chicken & mozzarella
$7.99
Hot Honey Heater
Pizza sauce, extra pepperoni and extra mozzarella, drizzled with hot honey
$7.99
Meat Deluxe
Pizza sauce, Italian sausage, pepperoni, bacon, ground beef & mozzarella
$7.99
Chicken Alfredo
Alfredo sauce, garlic, spinach, onion, tomato, bacon, chicken & mozzarella
$8.29
Margarita Pizza
Garlic butter sauce, garlic, spinach, tomato, oregano & mozzarella
$7.99
Papa Smokey
Sweet BBQ sauce, chicken, bacon, onion, mozzarella and cheddar, drizzled with chipotle ranch
$7.99
Red Hot Rancher
Ranch sauce, onion, bacon, diced chicken, mozzarella & cheddar, Franks red hot sauce
$7.99
Papa's Pizza
Thick Crust (Hand Tossed)
$10.99
Thin Crust
$10.99
Pam's Style Pizza
Deep Dish
$5.99
Calzones
Calzone
Your favorite pizza with a twist
$8.49
Gluten Free
10" Gluten Free Pizza
Your go-to cauliflower crust
$13.99
Jimmy's Munchies
Cheese Curds
White Wisconsin cheddar cheese curds lightly dusted with a golden coating
$8.49
Fried Pickles
Fresh garden pickles, thick sliced in a golden breading, w/ sweet basil & garlic
$7.99
Spicy Cheese Curds
Fresh Wisconsin cheese curds with an authentic taste and spicy kick
$8.49
Breadsticks
Freshly baked smothered with garlic butter & parmesan served with marinara
$6.49
Cheese Bread
Our garlic bread topped with mozzarella baked to perfection
$5.99
Garlic Bread
Baked & smothered with garlic butter
$3.99
Cheese Breadsticks
Our breadsticks topped with mozzarella baked to perfection
$7.99
Zesty Cheese Breadsticks
Our cheese sticks sprinkled with our zesty seasoning blend
$7.99
Cinnamon Sticks
Freshly baked smothered with butter & cinnamon sugar, homemade frosting
$6.49
The Pizza Melt
Garlic bread, spread with pizza sauce, toppings of your choice and mozzarella
$7.99
French Fries
A fluffy, buttery potato flavor inside and a crisp, textured exterior
$2.99
Fried Cheesy Ravioli
Crispy pasta pocket filled with melted ricotta cheese, w/ signature marinara
$8.49
Mozzarella Sticks
7 crispy delicious sticks made with real Wisconsin mozzarella, w/ marinara
$7.99
Chicken Wings
Drummies and paddles by the pound, naked with choice of dipping sauce
$10.99
Spicy Chicken Bites
Hot & spicy bite sized chunks of chicken, 3/4 lb with dipping sauce
$10.99
Chicken Strips
Crispy, juicy tenderness & seasoned to perfection, 10oz with dipping sauce
$9.99
Bag O' Chips
Lays Sour Cream & Onion, Miss Vickie's Sea Salt, Smokehouse BBQ, and more
$1.49
Pasta
Homemade Lasagna
Ribbon noodles with italian sausage, veggies & four cheese blend, in marinara
$11.99
Jumbo Ravioli
Six jumbo pieces of beef or cheese raviolis smothered in signature marinara
$10.99
Spaghetti
Classic spaghetti noodles covered in our signature marinara sauce
$8.99
Mac & Cheese
Our signature homemade macaroni & cheese
$9.99
Subs
Ham
8" white or wheat hoagie
$7.99
Turkey
8" white or wheat hoagie
$7.99
Tuna
8" white or wheat hoagie
$7.99
Meatball
Toasted hoagie filled with meatballs, mozzarella, marinara, green pepper & onion
$8.49
Club
Ham & Turkey
$7.99
Italian
Salami, Capicola, & Italian Dressing
$7.99
Vegetarian
Everything plus green pepper, mushroom, & black olive
$7.99
B.L.T.
Toasted hoagie with bacon, provolone, mayo, lettuce, tomato, black pepper & oregano
$8.49
Papa's Special
Oven toasted with Italian beef, pasta sauce, onion, green pepper, & mozzarella
$9.49
Chicago Italian Beef
Italian beef, provolone, garlic butter, sauteed onions & peppers, au jus & giardiniera
$9.49
Toasted Chicken
Diced chicken, provolone, mayo, lettuce, tomato, onion, black pepper & oregano
$9.49
Chicken Bacon Rancher
Diced chicken, bacon, provolone, ranch, lettuce, tomato, onion, black pepper & oregano
$9.49
Salads
Small Salad
Individual size, with tomato, onion, black olive, mushroom, green pepper, cheddar
$6.99
Large Salad
Serves 2-3 people, with tomato, onion, black olive, mushroom, green pepper, cheddar
$13.99
Beverages
Can of Soda
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Diet MTN Dew, Starry, A&W Root Beer, Wild Cherry Pepsi
$1.59
Six Pack of Soda
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Diet MTN Dew, Starry, A&W Root Beer, Wild Cherry Pepsi
$6.99
2-Liter of Soda
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Diet MTN DEW, Mug Root Beer, Starry & Sugar Free Starry
$3.99
20oz Soda
$2.79
Juice Boxes
Apple, Berry, and Grape
$1.19
Milk
Available for dine in only
$1.29
Pure Leaf Lemon Tea
Brewed from REAL leaves. 0 Calories.
$2.99
Pure Leaf Sweet Tea
Made from REAL leaves. 0 Calories.
$2.99
Hog Wash
$1.99
Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream
Pint
$7.75
Quart
$14.50
Ice Cream
Kids Scoop
$3.90
Single Scoop
$4.50
Double Scoop
$6
Triple Scoop
$7.50
Single Waffle
$5.50
Double Waffle
$7
Cookie Sandwich
Many flavored sandwiches, try them rolled in a candy topping
$5.75
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$0.75
Three Cookie Special
$2
Shakes & Malts
Dutch Maid Vanilla ice cream, milk & flavoring blended to perfection
$8
Specialty Shake
Your favorite specialty flavor & milk blended to perfection
$8.50
Twister
Dutch Maid Vanilla ice cream mixed with your favorite candy
$8.50
Root Beer Float
Dutch Maid Vanilla & Mug Root beer
$5.50
Sundaes
Small Hot Fudge/Caramel
Vanilla ice cream topped with hot fudge or caramel, whipped cream & a cherry
$5.50
Large Hot Fudge/Caramel
Vanilla ice cream topped with hot fudge or caramel, whipped cream & a cherry
$7
Small Turtle
Vanilla ice cream, chocolate sauce, caramel, pecans, whipped cream & cherry
$6
Large Turtle
Vanilla ice cream, chocolate sauce, caramel, pecans, whipped cream & cherry
$7.50
PJ's Lunch Deals
One Regular Slice
Pepperoni or Sausage
$3.50
Two Regular Slices
$6
One Special Slice
Changes Daily
$4.50
Two Special Slices
$8.50
One Regular & Special Slice
$7.50
Two Breadsticks
$2
24oz Fountain Drink
$1.50
Subs on the Move
8" Sub & Chips
$9.50
8" Sub & Fries
$11
8" Sub & Curds
$14.50
Spoonini
what to order
Madison
New York
Los Angeles
Houston
Chicago
Dallas
Atlanta
Washington
Miami
Philadelphia
Boston
Phoenix
San Francisco
Detroit
Seattle
Riverside
Denver
Minneapolis
Tampa
San Diego
Orlando
Austin
Portland
Las Vegas
Baltimore
Charlotte
St. Louis
San Antonio
Pittsburgh
Nashville
Cincinnati
Cleveland
Kansas City
Columbus
Sacramento
Indianapolis
Virginia Beach
Jacksonville
San Jose
Providence
Oklahoma City
Milwaukee
Raleigh
Louisville
Richmond
Salt Lake City
Memphis
New Orleans
Hartford
Birmingham
Tulsa
Honolulu
Grand Rapids
Charleston
Greenville
Buffalo
Rochester
Bridgeport
Omaha
North Port
Albany
Knoxville
Columbia
Tucson
Albuquerque
Fresno
Baton Rouge
Dayton
Colorado Springs
El Paso
Cape Coral
Allentown
Boise
Little Rock
Des Moines
Madison
Akron
Oxnard
Portland
Kiryas Joel
Deltona
Greensboro
Worcester
Jackson
McAllen
Lexington
Wichita
Bakersfield
Chattanooga
New Haven
Myrtle Beach
Atlantic City
Palm Bay
Toledo
Syracuse
Fayetteville
Durham
Augusta
Reno
Provo
Winston-Salem
Harrisburg
Huntsville
Wilmington
Savannah
Lakeland
Stockton
Scranton
Pensacola
Spokane
Santa Rosa
Ogden
Springfield
Asheville
Lansing
Crestview
Naples
Lancaster
Fort Collins
Corpus Christi
Killeen
Port St. Lucie
Tallahassee
Boulder
Gulfport
Youngstown
Lafayette
Modesto
Santa Maria
Ann Arbor
Fayetteville
Springfield
Mobile
Shreveport
Manchester
Eugene
Canton
Montgomery
Fort Wayne
Lubbock
Salem
Trenton
Beaumont
Waterbury
Salinas
Vallejo
Columbus
Gainesville
Barnstable Town
Davenport
Norwich
York
Huntington
Spartanburg
Flint
Lincoln
Slidell
Brownsville
South Bend
Waco
Rockford
Anchorage
Reading
Peoria
College Station
San Luis Obispo
Visalia
Panama City
Green Bay
Roanoke
Bend
Hickory
Kingsport
Hilton Head Island
Kalamazoo
Ocala
Evansville
Sioux Falls
Daphne
Clarksville
Athens
Fargo
Hagerstown
Amarillo
Charlottesville
Kennewick
Longview
Utica
Lynchburg
Macon
Tyler
Olympia
Greeley
Cedar Rapids
Champaign
Medford
Burlington
Bellingham
Lake Charles
Erie
Appleton
Dishes
Places