APP OF THE MONTHFRIED GREEN TOMATOES CAPRESE HOUSE MADE RICOTTA BASIL OIL BALSAMIC GLAZE
$15
Fried Cheese Curds
$12
Fried PicklesTony Paco fried pickle chips
$10.50
FriesOur famous hand cut fries!
$9
Irish NachosMcCarthy’s chips topped with chopped corned beef and smothered in melted cheese, tomatoes scallions and topped with our house made sauce
$15
Kerry BoardOlives, cucumbers, pita chips and Eileen’s Dip with a choice of two cheeses - onion cheese, pepper jack, swiss, cheddar, Irish cheddar, provolone
$15
Loaded Spuds
Your choice of hand cut fries or tots POUTINE Deep fried cheese curds and fresh swiss topped with our Mushroom gravy CHILI CHEESE Homemade chili, shredded Monterey jack cheese and onion REUBEN Corned beef, sauerkraut and Swiss cheese with a drizzle of thousand island SHEPHERD‘S PIE Topped with Sheph
$15.50
Mccarthy's Chips & Eileen's Famous DipBasket full of McCarthy's homemade chips served with 2 sides of Eileen's dip.
$9
Pretzel Bites
$9
Scotch EggsA McCarthy's Tradition! Three hard boiled eggs, wrapped in tasty sausage, covered in bread crumbs and deep fried. Served with our chipotle ranch sauce.
$15.50
Reuben Skins
$13
Buffalo Chicken Dip
$12
Wings
Dozen
$19
Half Dozen
$13
Blarney Burgers
Blarney BurgerThe classic
Car Bomb BurgerHalf pound double with rasher bacon, Irish cheddar, grilled onions and smothered in Car Bomb sauce made with Guinness and Jameson
$19
Faddy O'bradGrilled cheese burger! Our half pound hand smashed burger sandwiched between two grilled cheese sandwiches. One grilled cheese is stuffed with pickles and the other is loaded with bacon. All stacked with lettuce and tomato. Killer of a sandwich!
$19.50
Full MickeyOur best seller! American, Swiss, provolone and cheddar cheeses. Rasher bacon, Harp grilled onions, portabella mushrooms and smothered in Guinness BBQ sauce.
$19
Truffle Shuffle
$19
Lamb Burger
$20
Smash Burger
$18
BURGER GG
$13
FLYING DUTCHMANCARB-LESS OPTION WITH A GRILLED ONION OR TOMATO AS A BUN
$12
Sandwiches
Sandwich of the MonthSPACED INVADER UFO PIZZA BURGER ITALIAN SAUSAGE & BURGER BLEND CLEVELAND LITTLE ITALY MARINARA HOUSE-MADE RICOTTA & BASIL OIL BRIOCHE BUN BRUSHED WITH BLACK GARLIC BUTTER & PARM PRESSED INTO A UFO
$18
Mother CluckerThe best chicken sandwich you will ever have! Lightly breaded chicken breast with lettuce, tomato, pickle and drizzled with a sriracha aoli
$15.50
Grilled Celtic ReubenYou've tried the rest. Now taste the best! Succulent corned beef slowly cooked in Smithwick's beer and whiskey topped with Swiss cheese, kraut and thousand island on marble rye.
$17.50
Salmon BLTNorwegian filet seared and served on a toasted brioche bun with creamy dill, spring mix, cucumber and tomato
$20.50
Guinness Fried BolognaThick slice of fried bologna topped with fried egg, pickled onions, American cheese and spicy Guinness Mustard all stacked between two slices of grilled marble rye.
$14.50
Perch SandwichPerch with lettuce and tomato, served on a toasted bun with a side of slaw & tartar.
$25
Paddys Pulled PorkA delicious BBQ pulled pork sandwich topped with pickle and served on a brioche bun
$14
Wraps
Buffalo Chicken WrapWe coat chicken chunks in buffalo sauce and roll them up with lettuce, cheese, tomatoes and ranch
$16
Perch WrapPerch, cole slaw, diced tomatoes, and shredded cheese, topped with our chipotle ranch sauce.
$22
Reuben WrapCorned beef, kraut, Swiss and thousand island.
$17
From Land & Sea
BoxtiesPotato pancakes that originated during the Irish famine and our boxties are true to heritage
$18
Corned Beef & CabbageSlow roasted in our own secret blend of seasonings, spices, Irish beer, whiskey, with of course a touch of magic from the wee folk. Served with mashed potatoes and cabbage.
$18
Fish N' Chips BasketCod beer battered and served atop McCarthy’s homemade chips with slaw and tarter.
$19.50
Garlic Marinated SirloinBeef tips cooked with mushrooms and onions and served with house vegetable and choice of potato*
$20
McCarthy's Shepherds PieSlow cooked ground beef with celery, carrots and mushrooms in a delicate pastry topped with mashed potatoes, mushroom gravy and cheese.
$18.50
Perch BasketHeaping mound of perch, lightly battered and flash fried, featuring McCarthy’s chips and fresh slaw.
$35
Walleye Bite Basket w/ Fries
$20
Soups/Salads
Potato Soup
$5
Chili
$5
Featured Soup
$5
Madison Street SaladMixed Greens with a sweet onion dressing, topped with seasoned almonds, bacon, feta cheese, tomatoes and red onions.
Farmhouse SaladFresh mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, shredded Monterey jack cheese, croutons and choice of dressing.
Finnegan's SaladMixed Greens, Feta cheese, sun-dried tomatoes, diced tomatoes, onion & seasoned almonds served with our sweet onion dressing and topped with parmesan garlic crusted portabella mushroom slices and fried pita wedges.
$17.50
Wild Colleen SaladBuffalo chicken atop mixed Greens, topped with cheese, tomatoes and red onion.