Best cookie in New York
3,027 places · updated Nov 2026
#1
The Pastry Box
4.9 · 12 ratings#2
William Greenberg Desserts
$27
4.7 · 90 ratings#3
Kossars
$4.25
4.7 · 15 ratings
- 44.6 · 21 ratings
- 54.4 · 16 ratings
3022 more · not ranked yet
- $2.50–50
- $2–90
- $0.75–3.99
- $3–49
- $3.07–124.79
- $1–64