Skip to content
Spoonini
what to order
Jimmy Hays Steak House menu · New York | Spoonini
New York
Jimmy Hays Steak House
Jimmy Hays Steak House
Directions
Call
Website
Menu
Wine by the Bottle
Wine by the Glass
Specialty Drinks
Jimmy's Collectables
Sandwiches
Chef's Suggestions
Salads
Starters
Meats
Fish
Wine by the Bottle
Piper-Heidsieck Brut, France – 375 ml
Domaine Carneros Brut, California
Piper-Heidsieck Brut, France – 750 ml
Moet & Chandon "Imperial," France
Veuve Cliequot Ponsardin, France
Veuve Clieqout Ponsardin Rosé, France
Dom Perignon, France
Sauvignon Blanc, Rodney Strong, Charlotte's Home, Sonoma County
Sauvignon Blanc, Heibel Ranch, Napa Valley
Sauvignon Blanc, Duckhorn Vineyards, Napa Valley
Sauvignon Blanc, Grgich Hills, Napa Valley
Sauvignon Blanc, Cakebread Cellars, Napa Valley
Masi Masianco, Italy
75% Pinot Grigio delle Venezie, 25% Verduzza
King Estate, Oregon
Santa Margherita, Italy
ChilensisReserva, Maule Valley, Chili
Louis Jadot, France
Rodney Strong, Russian River Valley, California
Bouchaine, Carneros, Napa Valley
King Estate, Oregon (Pinot Noir)
Simi, Sonoma County
Kenneth Volk (formerly Byron), Santa Barbara, California
Rosenblum Appellation Series, Pasa Robles
Francis Ford Coppola, Director's Cut, Dry Creek
Grgich Hills, Napa Valley (Zinfandel)
Rutherford Hills, Napa Valley
St. Francis, Sonoma County
Rodney Strong, Sonoma County
Markham, Napa Valley
Grgich Hills, Napa Valley (Merlot)
Duckhorn Vineyards, Napa Valley
Los Vascos Reserve, Chile
Charles Krug, Napa Valley
Beaulieu Vineyards, Napa Valley
St. Francis, Sonoma County (Cabernet)
Markham Vineyards, Napa Valley
Rodney Strong, Alexander Valley
Raymond Reserve, Napa Valley
Frog's Leap, Napa Valley
Sequoia Grove, Napa Valley
Rodney Strong Reserve, Sonoma County
Robert Craig "Affinity", Napa Valley
Heitz Cellar, Napa Valley
Chappellet, Napa Valley
Napanook by Christian Moueix, Dominus Estate
Newton, Unfiltered, Napa Valley
Joseph Phelps, Napa Valley
Jordan, Alexander Valley
Grgich Hills, Napa Valley (Cabernet)
Stag's Leap, Napa Valley
Groth, Oakville, Napa Valley
Rodney Strong Rockaway, Sonoma County
Rodney Strong Alexander's Crown, Sonoma County
Rodney Strong Brother's Ridge, Sonoma County
Duckhorn Vineyards, Napa Valley (Cabernet)
Inglenook, formerly Rubicon CASK, Napa Valley
Chimney Rock – Stags Leap District
Cakebread Cellars, Napa Valley
Silver Oak, Alexander Valley
Caymus, Napa Valley
Beringer, Private Reserve, Napa Valley
Robert Mondavi, Reserve, Napa Valley
La Linda, Malbec, Mendoza, Argentina
Louis Jadot, Beaujolais – Villages, Gamay, France
Saurus Select – Malbec, Argentina
Francis Ford Coppola, Black Label Claret
Villa Antinori, Toscana, Italy
Tenuta Julia, Amarone della Valpolicella, Italy
Chateau Plaisance, Saint Emilion Grand Cru, Bordeaux, France
Marchese Antinori, Chianti Classico Riserva, Italy
Terre, Barolo, Langhe, Italy
Roux, Pere, & Fils, Gevrey Chambertin Burgundy, France
La Roquete, Chateauneuf Du Pape, France
La Fortuna, Brunello di Montalcino, Italy
Rodney Strong, Symmetry, Meritage, Sonoma County
Gaja "Promis", Toscana, Italy
Ruffino, Riserva Ducale Oro, "Gold Label", Chianti, Italy
Masi Costasera Amarone, Lake Garda, Italy
Pio Cesare, Barolo, Piedmont, Nebbiolo
Tignanello, Antinori, Super Tuscan, Italy
Wine by the Glass
Veuve Cliequot, Brut, France
Heinz Eifel, Germany
New Harbor, Marlborough, New Zealand
Grgich Hills, Napa Valley (Fume Blanc)
Coppiere, Delle Venezie, Italy
Masi Masianco, Italy (glass)
Newton, Red Label, Napa Valley
Le Petit Rouviere, France
Beringer, California
Clos du Val, Napa County
Rodney Strong, Sonoma County (glass)
Newton, Red Label, Napa Valley (Cabernet)
Rutherford Ranch, Sonoma County
Four Vines, Old Vine Cuvee, California
Jacob's Creek, Australia
Altos Del Plata, Mendoza, Argentina
Villa Antinori Toscana, Italy (glass)
Chateau Recougne, France
Specialty Drinks
Jimmy's Bloody Bull
Absolut, beef broth, tomato juice, Worcestershire sauce & fresh lemon juice
Violet Eyes
Absolut Citron, Cointreau, blue curacao, cranberry juice & fresh lemon
Devil's Delight
Absolut Vanilla, Frangelico & lemon juice served in a sugar rimmed glass
French Martini
Grey Goose, Cointreau, Chambord & pineapple juice
Razzmopolitan
Absolut Raspberry, Cointreau, Rose's lime juice & a splash of cranberry juice
Easy Rita
Patron Silver, Cointreau & fresh lime juice served in a salt rimmed glass
The Governess
Stoli Ohranj, champagne & raspberry puree
Cool with a Kick
Crop Organic Cucumber, lime juice & raspberry puree
Very Berries
Stoli Blueberri, Absolut Raspberry, cranberry juice and strawberry puree
The Orchard
Grey Goose L'Poire, Smirnoff Apple, Absolut Citron & mango puree
Martini Colada
Absolut, Malibu Rum & a splash of pineapple juice
Chocolate Martini
Absolut Vanilla, Tia Maria & Godiva Chocolate liquor served in a chocolate laidened glass
Jimmy McCluskey's Delight
Grandfather's 1932 recipe; Mount Gay Barbados rum, fresh lime juice & sugar
Jimmy's Collectables
Beaulieu Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley
Merry Edwards Pinot Noir, Russian River Valley
Ridge "Geyserville" Red Zinfandel Based Blend
Robert Craig "Affinity" Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley
Grgich Hills Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley
Alexander Valley Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon, Sonoma County
"The Prisoner" Napa Valley Blend
51% Zinfandel, 19% Cabernet Sauvignon, 15% Syrah, 12% Petite Syrah, 2% Charbono, 1% Grenache
Chappellet, Signature Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley
Rodney Strong "Symmetry" Meritage, Alexander Valley
Jordan Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley
Heitz "Trailside Vineyard" Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley
Hewitt Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley
BV, Georges de Latour Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley
Del Dotto Ca' Nani 2011 Napa Valley Red Wine
71% Cabernet Franc, 25% Merlot & 4% Cabernet Sauvignon, aromas of rose petal, forest floor and earth
Hiatus 2008 Napa Valley Red, Julianna's Vineyard, Pope Valley
39% Syrah, 30% Cabernet Franc, 22% Petite Sirah, dark fruits framed by toasty oak
Hug Cellars 2010 Cabernet Sauvignon, Starr Ranch Paso Robles
100% Cabernet Sauvignon, dark red fruit, cassis, raspberry and white pepper
Flowers 2012 Pinot Noir, Sonoma Coast
Expressive wine showcasing the diversity of the rugged Sonoma Coast
Domaine Serene 2010 Yamhill Cuvee, Pinot Noir, Willamette Valley
Lively, lithe and inviting red with red fruit, floral and spice overtones
Razi Winery 2009 Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley
100% Cabernet Sauvignon, rich and balanced with berries, oak, ripe cherry
"Animo" 2010 Napa Valley
83% Cabernet Sauvignon, 17% Petit Verdot, laced with ash, plum, graphite, smoke
Heitz Cellars "Trailside Vineyard" 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley
Franciscan Magnificat 2011 Napa Valley Meritage
64% Cabernet Sauvignon, 26% Merlot, 5% Petit Verdot, aged 20 months in oak
Caymus 2012 40th Anniversary Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley
Liter bottle
Groth, Oakville, Special Reserve 2010 Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley
Sandwiches
Jimmy Hays Steak Sandwich
Sliced filet mignon with sautéed vidalia onions and melted fontina cheese on toasted garlic bread
Mc Cluskey's Bar Burger
Ground porterhouse steak with lettuce, tomato and white onion
Filet Mignon Sliders
Three sliced filet mignon sandwiches topped with béarnaise on Martin potato rolls
Crab Cake Sandwich
With apple wood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato and tartar sauce on a Martin potato roll
Grilled Chicken Paillard Sandwich
With apple smoked bacon, tomato, melted crumbled bleu cheese and lemon herb mayonnaise
Open Faced Steak Sandwich
Sliced filet mignon topped with jalapeno, onion and melted fontina cheese on garlic bread
Veal Meatball Sliders
Three homemade veal meatballs topped with veal demi glaze on Martin potato rolls
Chef's Suggestions
Lobster Thermidor
De-shelled steamed lobster in lobster mushroom cream sauce, topped with Parmesan
The Skewer
Shrimp, chicken, filet mignon and peppers over broiled tomatoes & onions with aioli
Florentine Oysters
Sautéed oysters over bedded spinach with a light white wine fennel sauce
St. Peter's Fish
Pan roasted tilapia topped with cucumber, tomatoes and bell peppers, citrus vinaigrette
Shrimp Fried Lollipops
Four fried shrimp lollipops atop allumette potatoes with remoulade and cocktail sauce
Salads
Warm Capon Salad
Breaded julienne chicken breast over mesculin greens, bacon, tomatoes, honey mustard
Surf & Turf Salad
Sliced filet mignon, broiled shrimp, tomato, onion & mozzarella with balsamic reduction
Steak Salad
Sliced filet mignon, romaine, apple slices, cranberries and bleu cheese, maple dijon vinaigrette
Shrimp Salad
Grilled shrimp over romaine, avocado and heirloom tomatoes, honey lemoncello vinaigrette
Lobster Club Salad
Maine lobster, iceberg lettuce, bacon and tomato in thousand island dressing
Cobb Salad
Grilled chicken, bacon, mescluin greens, bleu cheese, avocado, egg, tomatoes, olives
Market Salad
Choice of Italian, French, Russian, Honey Mustard or classic Red Roquefort dressing
Michael Cohen's Lobster Salad
Maine lobster, bacon, chopped lettuce, tomato, light thousand island dressing
Heart of Lettuce and Tomato
With bacon & crumbled bleu cheese
Sliced Tomato and Red Onion
Warm Goat Cheese Salad
Mesclun greens, bacon, croutons, caramelized cashews, balsamic dressing
The "Donald Schwartz" Salad
Chopped iceberg, bacon, tomatoes, lite mayonnaise dressing
Beet Salad
Red and golden beet roots, artichoke hearts, blue cheese, pine nuts, cherry tomatoes
Chopped Italian Salad
Dilusso salami, provolone, diced tomato, cucumber, extra virgin olive oil, balsamic
Caesar Salad
With shaved fresh parmigiano reggiano
Heirloom Tomato & Fresh Mozzarella
Starters
Daily Soup
Lobster Bisque
Maryland Crab Cakes
Over alumette potatoes with roasted red peppers and corn salsa
Shrimp Scampi Casserole
With roasted garlic and lemon herb demi glace
Colossal Lump Crabmeat Cocktail
Clams on the Half Shell (cold)
Baked Middle Neck Clams
Baked Blue Point Oysters (12)
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail (4)
Fried Calamari
With marinara sauce
Zucchini Fritti
With marinara sauce
Shi-Ta-Ke Mushrooms
Sautéed over warm leaf spinach with a mushroom demi glace
Roasted Garlic Bread
With gorgonzola sauce
Slab of Apple Wood Smoked Bacon
One slice
Veal Meatball Encasserole
Oysters Rockafeller
Lobster Thermidor (Starter)
Baked de-shelled lobster sautéed in mushroom cream sauce, topped with Parmesan
Meats
In House Dry-Aged 18 oz New York Cut
Served on the bone with McCluskey's onion rings
Filet Mignon
With McCluskey's onion rings
Medallions of Filet Mignon Au Poivre
Pan seared with cracked pepper corns over creamy brandy sauce with mushroom caps
Medallions of Filet Mignon with Crabmeat
Sautéed with colossal crabmeat and fresh asparagus in a lite demi glace sauce
Filet of Beef Stroganoff
Sautéed with egg fettuccine pasta in a lite sour cream sauce
Sliced Steak for Two
With McCluskey's onion rings
Chateaubriand for Two
With McCluskey's onion rings
Beef Wellington Filet Mignon
Mushroom duxelle baked in puff pastry topped with béarnaise, with steamed asparagus
Two Double Thick American Loin Lamb Chops
With steamed mixed vegetables
Pork Chops
Broiled with caramelized granny smith apples
Chopped Steak 12 oz
With sautéed onions and demi glace
Calves Liver
With sautéed onions and sautéed leaf spinach
Fish
Maine Lobster
Broiled or Jimmy Style pan seared with cognac lemon garlic sauce over alumette potatoes
Shrimp Hays
Sautéed in lemon, garlic and white wine sauce over wild rice with peppers and peas
Fresh Sea Scallops
Broiled, served over sautéed leaf spinach
Seafood Francis
Sautéed shrimp, lobster and scallops in white wine lobster infused butter over spinach
Fried Shrimp
With remoulade and cocktail sauce over alumette potatoes
Cioppino Bouillabasse Stew
Fish, scallops, mussels, shrimp and clams with vegetable and fresh tomatoes
St. Peter's Fish with Shrimp and Scallops
White wine herb sauce, shi-ta-ke mushrooms, garlic and tomatoes over potatoes and spinach
Dover Sole
Pan seared over spinach, lemon butter herb sauce, capers, tomatoes and potato croquets
Spoonini
what to order
New York
New York
Los Angeles
Houston
Chicago
Dallas
Atlanta
Washington
Miami
Philadelphia
Boston
Phoenix
San Francisco
Detroit
Seattle
Riverside
Denver
Minneapolis
Tampa
San Diego
Orlando
Austin
Portland
Las Vegas
Baltimore
Charlotte
St. Louis
San Antonio
Pittsburgh
Nashville
Cincinnati
Cleveland
Kansas City
Columbus
Sacramento
Indianapolis
Virginia Beach
Jacksonville
San Jose
Providence
Oklahoma City
Milwaukee
Raleigh
Louisville
Richmond
Salt Lake City
Memphis
New Orleans
Hartford
Birmingham
Tulsa
Honolulu
Grand Rapids
Charleston
Greenville
Buffalo
Rochester
Bridgeport
Omaha
North Port
Albany
Knoxville
Columbia
Tucson
Albuquerque
Fresno
Baton Rouge
Dayton
Colorado Springs
El Paso
Cape Coral
Allentown
Boise
Little Rock
Des Moines
Madison
Akron
Oxnard
Portland
Kiryas Joel
Deltona
Greensboro
Worcester
Jackson
McAllen
Lexington
Wichita
Bakersfield
Chattanooga
New Haven
Myrtle Beach
Atlantic City
Palm Bay
Toledo
Syracuse
Fayetteville
Durham
Augusta
Reno
Provo
Winston-Salem
Harrisburg
Huntsville
Wilmington
Savannah
Lakeland
Stockton
Scranton
Pensacola
Spokane
Santa Rosa
Ogden
Springfield
Asheville
Lansing
Crestview
Naples
Lancaster
Fort Collins
Corpus Christi
Killeen
Port St. Lucie
Tallahassee
Boulder
Gulfport
Youngstown
Lafayette
Modesto
Santa Maria
Ann Arbor
Fayetteville
Springfield
Mobile
Shreveport
Manchester
Eugene
Canton
Montgomery
Fort Wayne
Lubbock
Salem
Trenton
Beaumont
Waterbury
Salinas
Vallejo
Columbus
Gainesville
Barnstable Town
Davenport
Norwich
York
Huntington
Spartanburg
Flint
Lincoln
Slidell
Brownsville
South Bend
Waco
Rockford
Anchorage
Reading
Peoria
College Station
San Luis Obispo
Visalia
Panama City
Green Bay
Roanoke
Bend
Hickory
Kingsport
Hilton Head Island
Kalamazoo
Ocala
Evansville
Sioux Falls
Daphne
Clarksville
Athens
Fargo
Hagerstown
Amarillo
Charlottesville
Kennewick
Longview
Utica
Lynchburg
Macon
Tyler
Olympia
Greeley
Cedar Rapids
Champaign
Medford
Burlington
Bellingham
Lake Charles
Erie
Appleton
Dishes
Places