Junior ScoopOne junior scoop of Hersheys ice cream - 1 flavor. 3.5 oz serving.
$3.52
Hand Packed PintYou pick the flavor and we'll pack it! 1 or 2 flavors. 16 oz.
$9.23
Hand Packed QuartYou pick the flavor and we'll pack it! 1 or 2 flavors. 32 oz.
$13.95
Single ScoopAn ample scoop of Hersheys ice cream - 1 flavor. 5 oz serving.
$4.60
Double Junior ScoopTwo junior scoops of Hersheys ice cream - 1 or 2 flavors. 6 oz serving.
$5.58
Triple ScoopThree ample scoops of Hersheys ice cream - 1, 2, or 3 flavors. 16 oz serving.
$8.77
Double ScoopTwo ample scoops of Hersheys ice cream - 1 or 2 flavors. 10 oz serving.
$7.08
Non-Dairy Ice Cream (Oat-Based)
Junior Scoop Non-DairyA junior scoop of Hersheys Non-Dairy Oat-Based ice cream or sorbet/Italian ice- 1 flavor. 3.5 oz serving.
$4
Single Scoop Non-DairyAn ample scoop of Hersheys Non-Dairy Oat-Based ice cream or sorbet/Italian ice- 1 flavor. 5 oz serving.
$5.50
Double Junior Scoop Non-DairyTwo junior scoops of Hersheys Non-Dairy Oat-Based ice cream or sorbet/Italian ice- 1 or 2 flavors. 6 oz serving.
$6.50
Double Scoop Non-DairyTwo ample scoops of Hersheys Non-Dairy Oat-Based ice cream or sorbet/Italian ice- 1 or 2 flavors. 10 oz serving.
$8.50
Triple Scoop Non-DairyThree ample scoops of Hersheys Non-Dairy Oat-Based ice cream or sorbet/Italian ice- 1, 2 or 3 flavors. 16 oz serving.
$10.50
Hand Packed Pint Non-DairyYou pick the non-dairy flavor (either oat-based ice cream or sorbet/Italian ice) and we'll pack it! 1 or 2 flavors. 16 oz.
$10.50
Hand Packed Quart Non-DairyYou pick the non-dairy flavor (either oat-based ice cream or sorbet/Italian ice) and we'll pack it! 1 or 2 flavors. 32 oz.
$17.50
Small Shake Non-DairyChoice of oat-based ice cream, sorbets, or Italian ice mixed with oat milk or seltzer for a refreshing non-dairy experience. 16 oz.
$9
Large Shake Non-DairyChoice of oat-based ice cream, sorbets, or Italian ice mixed with oat milk or seltzer for a refreshing non-dairy experience. 24 oz.
$12
Soft Serv Ice Cream
Small Soft ServA small cup of Soft Serv ice cream - Vanilla, Chocolate, or Twist flavor. 5 oz serving.
$4.60
Medium Soft ServA medium cup of Soft Serv ice cream - Vanilla, Chocolate, or Twist flavor. 10 oz serving.
$6.52
Large Soft ServA large cup of Soft Serv ice cream - Vanilla, Chocolate, or Twist flavor. 16 oz serving.
$7.50
Junior Soft ServA junior cup of Soft Serv ice cream - Vanilla, Chocolate, or Twist flavor. 3.5 oz serving.
$3.52
Ice Cream Concoctions
SundaeThe ultimate American classic - an ample scoop of Hersheys ice cream (1 flavor) plus 2 toppings. A magical treat! 5 oz plus toppings!
$7.27
Ice Cream Float2 junior scoops of ice cream in your choice of seltzer or soft drink! An American classic! 16 oz serving
$6.38
Extreme Sundae2 scoops of Hersheys ice cream (1 or 2 flavors) plus 3 toppings. A huge treat! 10 oz plus toppings!
$9.14
Banana SplitClassic combination of split banana, 3 scoops of ice cream of your choice, topped with your choice of toppings - an American classic!
$9.61
Hersheys PrePacked PintsA ready to go take-out prepacked pint from Hersheys - available in a dozen popular flavors - 16 oz. Serves 3-5
$8.20
Small ShakeA McCools classic - unlimited flavors. Best Milkshake in New Jersey - 16 oz
$7.46
Large ShakeA McCools classic - unlimited flavors. Best Milkshake in New Jersey - 24 oz
$8.67
Gift Cards
Gift Cards
$5
Gift Cards
$10
Gift Cards
$15
Gift Cards
$20
Gift Cards
$25
Gift Cards
$50
Gift Cards
$100
Blend-Ins
Small Yogurt Blend-InA McCools original - choose 3 lo-fat yogurt bases (vanilla, chocolate, coffee) and blend in your choice of fruit, toppings, and other blend-ins. 6 oz.
$5.49
Quart Yogurt Blend-InA McCools original - choose 3 lo-fat yogurt bases (vanilla, chocolate, coffee) and blend in your choice of fruit, toppings, and other blend-ins. 32 oz.
$14.96
Medium Yogurt Blend-InA McCools original - choose 3 lo-fat yogurt bases (vanilla, chocolate, coffee) and blend in your choice of fruit, toppings, and other blend-ins. 10 oz.
$7.88
Large Yogurt Blend-InA McCools original - choose 3 lo-fat yogurt bases (vanilla, chocolate, coffee) and blend in your choice of fruit, toppings, and other blend-ins. 16 oz.
$9.57
Famous Recipes
Medium Yogurt RecipeA McCools original - choose among 3 dozen favorite recipes based on Madison and Summit area culture! 3 lo-fat yogurt bases (vanilla, chocolate, coffee) available . 10 oz.
$7.88
Small Yogurt RecipeA McCools original - choose among 3 dozen favorite recipes based on Madison and Summit area culture! 3 lo-fat yogurt bases (vanilla, chocolate, coffee) available . 6 oz.
$5.49
Quart Yogurt RecipeA McCools original - choose among 3 dozen favorite recipes based on Madison and Summit area culture! 3 lo-fat yogurt bases (vanilla, chocolate, coffee) available . 32 oz.
$14.96
Large Yogurt RecipeA McCools original - choose among 3 dozen favorite recipes based on Madison and Summit area culture! 3 lo-fat yogurt bases (vanilla, chocolate, coffee) available . 16 oz.
$9.57
Novelties/Toppings/Cones
Frosty BonesShow your favorite family member love - 2 dog biscuits filled with vanilla soft serv. Ruff!!!
$1.31
McCoolwhichMcCools famous McCoolwich - huge chocolate chip cookie filled with vanilla soft serv and coated with chocolate chips or rainbow sprinkles.
$4.38
MiniCoolwhichMcCools famous MiniCoolwhich - small chocolate chip cookie filled with vanilla soft serv and coated with chocolate chips or rainbow sprinkles.
$2.77
6 Pk MiniCoolwhich6 of McCools famous MiniCoolwhichs in a take out pack - small chocolate chip cookie filled with vanilla soft serv and coated with chocolate chips or rainbow sprinkles.
$14.75
Toppings To GoToppings of your choice - will be packaged in 4 oz cups separately from your order.
Cones To GoCones of your choice - will be packaged separately from your order.
4 Pk McCoolwhich4 of McCools famous Chipwhichs in a take out pack - huge chocolate chip cookie filled with vanilla soft serv and coated with chocolate chips or rainbow sprinkles.