Classic Lobster Roll (Guppy)Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$32.24
Classic Lobster Roll (Shark)Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$40.56
Classic Lobster Roll (Whale)Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$54.07
Hamptons Lobster Roll (Guppy)Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$32.24
Hamptons Lobster Roll (Shark)Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$40.56
Hamptons Lobster Roll (Whale)Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$54.07
BLT Lobster Roll (Guppy)Fresh poached lobster Classic style tossed with bacon, lettuce and tomato on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$32.24
BLT Lobster Roll (Shark)Fresh poached lobster Classic style tossed with bacon, lettuce and tomato on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$40.56
BLT Lobster Roll (Whale)Fresh poached lobster Classic style tossed with bacon, lettuce and tomato on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$54.07
BLT Roll (No Lobster)
$12.48
Cajun Lobster Roll (Guppy)Fresh poached lobster with warm sauteed peppers and spicy mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$32.24
Cajun Lobster Roll (Shark)Fresh poached lobster with warm sauteed peppers and spicy mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$40.56
Cajun Lobster Roll (Whale)Fresh poached lobster with warm sauteed peppers and spicy mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$54.07
Diavolo Lobster Roll (Guppy)Fresh poached lobster tossed with roasted tomatoes and peperoncino on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$32.24
Diavolo Lobster Roll (Shark)Fresh poached lobster tossed with roasted tomatoes and peperoncino on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$40.56
Diavolo Lobster Roll (Whale)Fresh poached lobster tossed with roasted tomatoes and peperoncino on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$54.07
Shinnecock Lobster Roll (Guppy)Fresh poached lobster tossed with a little extra virgin olive oil, lemon, arugula on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$32.24
Shinnecock Lobster Roll (Shark)Fresh poached lobster tossed with a little extra virgin olive oil, lemon, arugula on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$40.56
Shinnecock Lobster Roll (Whale)Fresh poached lobster tossed with a little extra virgin olive oil, lemon, arugula on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$54.07
Lobster Salad
Lobster Salad (Guppy)Fresh poached lobster tossed with house greens + corn + cucumbers + tomatoes/ citrus vinaigrette
$32.24
Lobster Salad (Shark)Fresh poached lobster tossed with house greens + corn + cucumbers + tomatoes/ citrus vinaigrette
$40.56
Lobster Salad (Whale)Fresh poached lobster tossed with house greens + corn + cucumbers + tomatoes/ citrus vinaigrette
$54.07
Seafood
Lobster Fritters(6) Tempura battered fried lobster bites / side of chipotle aioli dipping sauce
$21.84
Lobster MeltFresh poached Lobster meat with slaw, sauce and cheese / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$26
Lobster TacosFresh poached Lobster tossed with warm marinated mixed peppers on two grilled tortillas with arugula, guacamole and tomatoes
$26
Fried Fish Platter
$18.72
Soups
Lobster Bisque“The Best” bisque you can find! Fresh poached lobster in broth transformed into deliseaous soup (touch of cream)
$21.84
Shinnecock Clam ChowderHearty local clam soup with classic vegetables (tomato base) + toasted bread
$14.56
Burgers
Crab Cake BurgerHouse-made Jumbo Lump crab cake burger / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$18.72
Salmon BurgerSignature house-made Atlantic Salmon patty Grilled to perfection / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$18.72
Tuna BurgerSignature house-made local yellowfin tuna burger (local catch)/ Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$18.72
Fish Burger
$16.64
Sides
Local Sweet Corn
$4.16
Mexi Corn
$6.24
Regular Fries
$5.20
1/2 Pan Of Chips
$20.80
Pasta Dinner
Lobster Mac & CheeseOur famous chef’s lobster mac has fresh poached lobster with 4 cheese blend + elbow pasta / toasted penko crust
$22.88
Mac & Cheese (No Lobster)
$12.48
Lobster Fra Diavolo PastaAn unforgettable pasta dish with fresh poached lobster meat tossed with spicy fra diavolo sauce (roasted tomatoes) + spaghetti
$36.40
Lobster RavioliDecadent + Deliseaous! Fresh poached lobster filling enveloped in thin pasta dough and tossed with a roasted tomato cream sauce (hint of spicy heat) + blended with more lobster meat
$33.28
Kids Menu
Kids Chicken Fingers
$14.56
Kids Side of Fries
$3.12
Whole Lobster
1 1/4 lbs Whole LobsterWhole Maine Lobster Steamed & Cracked (ready to eat)
$54.07
1 1/2 Whole LobsterWhole Maine Lobster Steamed & Cracked (ready to eat) / served with baked potato + cole slaw + corn on cob
$68.63
2 lbs Whole LobsterWhole Maine Lobster Steamed & Cracked (ready to eat)
$90.47
Montauk Drinks
Montauk Pink Lemonade
$4.68
Montauk Lemon Tea
$4.68
Montauk Raspberry
$4.68
Montauk Southern Sweet Tea
$4.68
Montauk White Tea
$4.68
Montauk Green Tea
$4.68
Montauk Lemonade
$4.68
Montauk Half & Half
$4.68
Montauk Mango Green Tea
$4.68
Montauk Orange Clementine
$4.68
Montauk Diet Sweet Tea
$4.68
Soda
Coke Can
$2.08
Sprite Can
$2.08
Diet Coke Can
$2.08
Water
Water
$3.35
San Pellegrino
San Pellegrino Aranciata Rossa
$3.12
San Pellegrino Limonata
$3.12
San Pellegrino Arancia & Fico D'India
$3.12
San Pellegrino Melograno & Arancia
$3.12
Airport
Lobster MeltFresh poached Lobster meat with slaw, sauce and cheese / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$26
Mexi Corn
$6.24
Lobster Fritters(6) Tempura battered fried lobster bites / side of chipotle aioli dipping sauce
$21.84
Food Truck - Gas Station (Highway)
Shinnecock Lobster Roll (Guppy)Fresh poached lobster tossed with a little extra virgin olive oil, lemon, arugula on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$32.24
Shinnecock Lobster Roll (Shark)Fresh poached lobster tossed with a little extra virgin olive oil, lemon, arugula on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$40.56
Shinnecock Lobster Roll (Whale)Fresh poached lobster tossed with a little extra virgin olive oil, lemon, arugula on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$54.07
Lobster Fritters(6) Tempura battered fried lobster bites / side of chipotle aioli dipping sauce
$21.84
Lobster Mac & CheeseOur famous chef’s lobster mac has fresh poached lobster with 4 cheese blend + elbow pasta / toasted penko crust
$22.88
Mexi Corn
$6.24
Hamptons Lobster Roll (Guppy)Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$32.24
Hamptons Lobster Roll (Shark)Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$40.56
Hamptons Lobster Roll (Whale)Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$54.07
Lobster Bisque“The Best” bisque you can find! Fresh poached lobster in broth transformed into deliseaous soup (touch of cream)
$21.84
Classic Lobster Roll (Guppy)Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$32.24
Classic Lobster Roll (Shark)Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$40.56
Classic Lobster Roll (Whale)Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$54.07
Wolffer
Lobster Mac & CheeseOur famous chef’s lobster mac has fresh poached lobster with 4 cheese blend + elbow pasta / toasted penko crust
$22.88
Mac & Cheese (No Lobster)
$12.48
HFAF - Food Truck
Crab Cake BurgerHouse-made Jumbo Lump crab cake burger / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
$18.72
Lobster Mac & CheeseOur famous chef’s lobster mac has fresh poached lobster with 4 cheese blend + elbow pasta / toasted penko crust