Vegan Chili Bean & "Cheese"A mildly spiced vegan bean chili, with peppers and onions, and plant-based "cheese". So delicious!
$8.95
Butter ChickenMild tomato-based Indian curry. (In pie form, of course!) One of our most frequently requested flavors.
$8.95
Lamb PastyGround lamb, potato, onion, and rutabaga. Wrapped in our handmade pasty dough.
$8.95
Sausage RollHouse-ground pork sausage with caramelized onions and a hint of sage; wrapped in our buttery puff pastry. It's a favorite!
$7.75
Spinach, Feta & Chickpea RollOur meat-free version of a Sausage Roll. Spinach, puréed chickpeas, feta, onion, and a hint of sun-dried tomato and garlic. Wrapped in our house-made buttery puff pastry.
$7.75
Smoked Salmon, Leek & PotatoSmoked salmon, celery, onion, potato, and leek in a milk-based sauce.
$8.95
Savory Mince & CheeseFinely ground beef (aka mince) and mozzarella, in a tomato-based sauce with carrots, onions, celery, and rutabaga.
$8.95
Chicken & VegetableDiced chicken, carrots, onion, celery, and peas. Finished with cream.
$8.95
Pork & Peach BBQSlow-roasted pulled pork shoulder with onion, sage, and roasted peaches in a tangy barbeque sauce.
$8.95
Mac & CheeseMacaroni and cheese, with toasted Hanover tomatoes, IN A PIE!
$8.95
Steak & CheeseDiced steak & cheese in an onion gravy. A kiwi classic.
$8.95
Chili Bean & CheeseA favorite among our vegetarian options (even meat-eaters swoon over this pie!) A mildly spiced bean chili, with peppers, onions, and cheese.
$8.95
Whole Pies
Whole Pear & Almond TartClassic French-style tart (on steroids) with vanilla poached pears, almond frangipane, and flaked almonds.
$44
Whole Buttermilk & RaspberryA slice of heaven. Delicious raspberry compote bottom, topped with a lemon buttermilk custard.
$44
Whole BanoffeeA classic British dessert. Bananas, whipped English toffee and cream in an Anzac biscuit and graham cracker crust.
$44
Whole Key LimePossibly the best Key Lime pie ever.
Whole Mississippi MudDense, dark chocolate fudge in an Oreo cookie crust. Divine.
$44
Whole Coconut "Cream"A creamy coconut milk custard in an oat and coconut crust, topped with plant-based whipped cream and toasted coconut.
$44
Whole Chocolate Raspberry CreamDark chocolate creme patissiere, fresh raspberry coulis, whipped cream, and a cherry pecan brownie crust.
$44
Whole PecanClassic Pecan pie. Deep-dish. Made with extra love. (One might end up accepting a marriage proposal after consumption.)
$44
Whole Sour Cream & Wild Blueberry StreuselA staff favorite. Wild blueberries in a sour cream custard (almost akin to cheesecake) with a streusel topping. SO good!
$44
Whole Strawberry RhubarbA crowd favorite. Just the right amount of sweet and tart. Vegan double-crust pie.
$44
Whole Maple PecanCinnamon toasted pecan with a maple croissant batter and topped with lattice. Beautiful AND delicious fall flavor!
$44
Whole Dutch AppleRoasted apples in a pate brisée topped with a cinnamon and brown sugar streusel. Vegan.
$44
Sweet by the Slice
Pear & Almond TartClassic French-style tart (on steroids) with vanilla poached pears, almond frangipane, and flaked almonds.
$7.95
Buttermilk & RaspberryA slice of heaven. Delicious raspberry compote bottom, topped with a lemon buttermilk custard.
$7.95
Key LimePossibly the best Key Lime pie ever.
$7.95
Chocolate Raspberry CreamDark chocolate creme patissiere, fresh raspberry coulis, whipped cream, and a cherry pecan brownie crust.
$7.95
PecanClassic Pecan pie. Deep-dish. Made with extra love. (One might end up accepting a marriage proposal after consumption.)
$7.95
Sour Cream & Wild Blueberry StreuselA staff favorite. Wild blueberries in a sour cream custard (almost akin to cheesecake) with a streusel topping. SO good!
$7.95
Strawberry RhubarbA crowd favorite. Just the right amount of sweet and tart. Vegan double-crust pie.
$7.95
Mississippi MudDense, dark chocolate fudge in an Oreo cookie crust. Divine.
$7.95
Coconut "Cream"A creamy coconut milk custard in an oat and coconut crust, topped with plant-based whipped cream and toasted coconut.
$7.95
BanoffeeA classic British dessert. Bananas, whipped English toffee, and whipped cream in an Anzac biscuit and graham cracker crust.
$7.95
Maple PecanCinnamon toasted pecans with a maple croissant batter and topped with lattice. Beautiful AND delicious fall flavor!
$7.95
Dutch AppleRoasted apples in a pate brisee topped with a cinnamon and brown sugar streusel. Vegan.
$7.95
Lemon ChessThe classic southern pie with lemon, buttermilk & cornmeal custard.
$7.95
Proper Merch
Proper Magnet3 inch Proper Pie Co. magnet
$3
Proper Sticker3 inch Proper Pie Co. sticker
$2
Proper MugThe classic version!
$7
2024 Proper Pi Day MugThe official annual Pi Day mug is here! Happy Pi day!
$7
2025 Proper Pi Day MugThe official annual Pi Day mug is here! Happy Pi day!
$7
Proper Pint glass
$7
Proper PencilPencils are awesome
$1
2026 Proper Pi Day MugThe official annual Pi Day mug is here! Happy Pi day!
$7
Sweet As!
Anzac BiscuitA crunchy oatmeal and coconut cookie made with golden syrup. A delicious antipodean classic.
$2.50
Hand-Whipped CreamAdd a big dollop of our hand-whipped cream. (Comes on the side.)
$0.75
To Drink
Coke Zero
$2.75
IBC Root BeerDelicious frosty root beer!
$3.75
FantaFanta made in Mexico with real cane sugar.
$3.75
Blanchard's CoffeeHot and fresh, locally-roasted Handshake blend by our friends at Blanchard's. If you don't like it straight up, add some milk or sugar. We've got you!
$3.75
Cuppa Hot TeaPG Tips
$3.50
Bundaberg Ginger BeerCraft-brewed, non-alcoholic ginger beer from Australia.
$4
Diet Coke
$2.75
MexicokeCoca-Cola made in Mexico with real cane sugar.
$3.75
H2O2Go2 parts Hydrogen, 1 part Oxygen. 24 oz. cup of ice water to go.
$0.50
Iced CoffeeFlash-brewed locally-roasted Handshake blend by our friends at Blanchard's. If you don't like it straight up, add some milk or sugar. We've got you!