Lemon Cream Piea sweet yet tart lemon pie, baked in the most perfect, buttery, slightly salted graham cracker crust and topped with whipped cream.
$50
Lemon Blueberry CreamOur famous sweet and salty graham cracker crust, tart lemon filling, blueberry puree, and whipped cream. Heaven.
$55
Coconut Cream PieMy homemade flaky pie crust filled with creamy, homemade vanilla pudding and toasted coconut, topped with sweetened coconut flakes — the customer who ordered this pie asked for blueberries on top. Usually, it’s just coconut.
$60
Lemon Huckleberry CreamMy sweet and salty graham cracker crust, filled with tart, fresh zested and juiced lemon cream filling, swirled with huckleberry coulis from Montana, and topped with fresh homemade vanilla whipped cream and more huckleberry coulis.
$60
Chocolate Cream PieClassic flaky, Oreo, or Graham cracker crust filled with creamy Lindt chocolate filling, and topped with fluffy vanilla whipped cream and Lindt chocolate shavings.
$60
Banana Cream Piefresh sliced bananas, homemade vanilla pudding made with fresh eggs and whole milk, and fresh homemade whipped cream in a graham cracker crust. Also available in flaky, classic crust.
$60
Lemon Raspberry CreamOur famous sweet and salty graham cracker crust, tart lemon filling, fresh raspberry puree, and whipped cream. Heaven.
$55
Death by ChocolateButtery Oreo crust, filled with chocolate cream, and topped with chocolate whipped cream, chocolate sauce, and chocolate shavings.
$60
Grasshopper pieButtery oreo crust, filled with chocolate cream, and topped with mint whipped cream and Andes mints.
$60
Key Lime PieOne of my most popular pies. Buttery graham cracker crust with a tart but sweet perfect key lime filling, topped with fresh whipped cream.
$50
Raspberry Key Lime PieA new offering. Buttery graham cracker crust with a tart but sweet perfect key lime filling, swirled with homemade raspberry puree, topped with whipped cream, lime, and raspberry puree.
$55
Featured and Seasonal
Raspberry Cream PieOur favorite seasonal spring pie! Our classic, buttery crust filled with a sweet vanilla cream cheese and whipped cream filling and topped with our amazing house made raspberry coulis.
$55
Fresh Strawberry PieClassic, flaky pie crust filled with fresh, hulled strawberries, and topped with a (Jell-o free!) strawberry glaze. Topped with fresh, homemade vanilla whipped cream.
$60
Lemon MeringueClassic, flaky, all butter crust, filled with smooth homemade lemon curd, and topped with silky swiss meringue and toasted to perfection. This pie is best enjoyed within 2 days.
$60
Chocolate Pies
Peanut Butter PieOreo cookie crust, filled with smooth peanut butter filling and topped with rich chocolate ganache and peanut butter cups. A chocolate peanut butter lovers dream.
$60
Brownie Chocolate PecanClassic, flaky crust filled with rich, fudge brownie filling and toasted pecans.
$55
Chocolate Chess Pie with Espresso Whipped CreamMy FAVORITE of all my chocolate pies! This pie has classic flaky crust, but the filling is the real star. Real Lindt chocolate bars, heavy cream, eggs, and butter are combined to make this incredibly rich and decadent pie. And I top the whole thing off with Espresso whipped cream, Lindt chocolate ba
$55
Autumn Favorites
Cinnamon Roll Apple Piemy classic homemade apple pie, with a twist- a Cinnamon roll top crust. My homemade flaky pie crust is swirled with butter, cinnamon, and brown sugar. It’s amazing. This pie not available in gluten-free.
$60
Pecan PieA classic with toasted pecans, brown sugar, vanilla, butter and a touch of cinnamon.
$55
Chocolate PecanA classic with toasted pecans, brown sugar, vanilla, butter, semisweet chocolate, and a touch of cinnamon.
$57
Classic Apple Pieflaky homemade pie crust, filled with granny smith apples and loads of cinnamon. Also available with a crumble topping.
$50
Pumpkin PieHomemade flaky pie crust, with smooth, creamy, sweet, and perfectly spiced pumpkin filling. *Decorated on Thanksgiving and Christmas holidays unless noted otherwise
$50
MURDER pie (available specific Oct dates only)AVAILABLE SPECIFIC DATES IN OCTOBER ONLY. Please make sure you choose one of these order dates when shopping, or your order will have to be rescheduled! Available on the following dates: October 7-9 October 14th thru October 31st Each of these pies is an individual work of art, so the faces will var
$75
Pie of the Month Membership Info
Pie of the Month Subscription for the FIRST Tuesday of every monthIf you are interested in joining Pie of the Month Club, please send an email to myrumblytumbly@gmail.com. Subscription Agreement for Rumbly in my Tumbly Pie Co. Pie of the Month Club -- $60 per month Terms and conditions for a monthly membership in the Rumbly in my Tumbly Pie Company Pie of the Mont
$1
Pie of the Month Membership for the SECOND Tuesday of every monthIf you are interested in joining Pie of the Month Club, please send an email to myrumblytumbly@gmail.com. Subscription Agreement for Rumbly in my Tumbly Pie Co. Pie of the Month Club -- $60 per month Terms and conditions for a monthly membership in the Rumbly in my Tumbly Pie Company Pie of the Mont
$1
Fruit Pies
Apple Berry PieApple pie mixed with NW Marion blackberries, cinnamon, and sugar in a delicious, flaky homemade crust. Available in regular or crumb topping.
$55
Blueberry PieSweet blueberries in a homemade flaky pie crust. Also available with a crumble topping.
$55
Marionberry Pieflaky homemade crust filled with sweet northwest Marion blackberries. Heaven with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.
$55
Cherry PieTart montmorency cherries in a homemade flaky pie crust. Also available with a crumble topping.
$60
Mixed Berry PieA mix of blackberries, blueberries, and raspberries in a homemade flaky pie crust. Also available in a crumble topping.
$55
Menu
Raspberry PieClassic, flaky crust filled with sweet raspberries and sugar.
$60
Cherry OR Apple Pecan CrumbOur classic flaky all butter crust filled with your choice of either tart Granny Smith Apples or tart Montmorency pie cherries and topped with the most delicious brown sugar butter and pecan crumble.
$60
The Brownie BusinessOur classic, flaky all butter pie crust filled with a fudgy brownie like filling and topped with light and fluffy peanut butter whipped cream, peanut butter cups, and chocolate drizzle.
$60
Gift Cards
Gift CardGive the gift of pie! Choose your amount in the drop down box. If you need your gift card mailed, please also add the $1.00 shipping item and enter the shipping address into the notes at checkout. Cards will be sent first class mail within 2 to 3 business days.
$1
Tiny Tumblys
Tiny Tumblys6 mini (4 inch) pies, in the flavor of your choice, each individually packaged in it's own mini pie box. Must be ordered in batches of six pies per flavor.