3MC Panini3 Meat + 1 Cheese made fresh daily deli's choice includes one spicy or mild condiment!
$9
Triple CheeseThree of our slice-able cheeses 1 as a feature on white or wholewheat depending on the day (:
$9
Farmhouse SubOur farmstead fresh Feta w/sliced mozzarella or provolone, cucumbers or equivalent on Ciabatta bread with a condiment of your choice spicy or mild. Call ahead to customize or choose at pick up 574.276.6918
$12
SODSandwich of the Day is an ever-changing always good work of sandwich art. It may have meat, it may be cheeseless (NOT unless requested), it may be panini-style or sub-style regardless it is always good!
$12
VeggedOur Triple Cheese with a total of 3 yummy Toppings loaded up based on the veggies we have readily available that day! Please put spicy or mild in the notes (:
$12
Italian SubOur 3 Meat + 1 Cheese on Ciabatta w/lettuce and spicy or mild condiment. Customize at pick up or call ahead 574.276.6918
$10
Dessert
GelatoOur J2K handspun all-natural gelati from cow or goat milk in ever varying flavors!
$6
TiramisuOne of our favorite Chicago Bakeries, clean label & amazing taste!
$5.50
Snack Kits
Cheese & Friends! (small)A mix of our most popular items available pick-up day provides for +2 people. 1 Fresh cup, 1 small Wedge or Round, 1 small Meat Stick, & 1 Vessel (Bruschettini or Bread)! Cheesemonger's Choice, please but any dietary restrictions or requests in the notes or call/text 574-276-6918. Enjoyable as is bu
$25
Cheese & Friends!A mix of our most popular items available pick-up day provides for approximately +4 people. 1 Fresh cup, 2 Firm 4-6 oz. Wedges, 1 Large Meat Stick, 1 Boujee Cheese Friend*, and a Baguette! Cheesemonger's choice but please put any dietary restrictions & requests in the notes as well as desired Cheese
$50
Cheese Subscription!Four cheeses are chosen each month in varying styles. We will feature three artisan domestics and one unfamiliar import. The selection will be based on what is in-season and tasting especially good (peaking) as well as new & experimental cheese only available in limited quantities. <br />All wedges
$25
Holiday Tin - small2 wedges J2K Cheese + 1 small UG Meatstick + a few Gold Chocolate Coins for prosperity in a Festive Holiday Tin! *Meatless option available in the form of boujee Nuts*
$25
Grocery
Cashew VeganMade in Chicago this amazing cashew cheese substitute is simply good & delicious regardless how you want to use it. Text/call ahead to find out if we have a savory or sweet offering and if we have the Dessert cup DO NOT skip it!
$13
Chocolate BarsBean-to-Bar local and regional handmade Chocolate from makers such as Violet Sky, Crow & Moss, and WM!
$6
Butter2 pounds of Amish hand-rolled Butter w/salt super creamy and on all of our sandwiches! OR (when available) 1 cup of Goat Butter
$12
Crisp, Crackers & CookiesThe selection includes Potter's hand-cut organic Crackers & Crisps from a mother & son team aka amazing duo from WI, Rustic Bakery's original organic sourdough crisps from Marin County, CA and other select small-batch goodness!
$8.99
MustardsYummy all natural Sweet & Spicy, Hot Pepper or Garlic Mustard you can just eat it by the spoonful but excellent with our Summer Sausage and on Sammies!
$6.99
Oil & Vinegar
$55
Jams, Jellies & HoneyA variety of some of the best cheese friends we could find!
$5.99
ChipsYummy single-serve Kettle Chips in a variety of flavors. Choice at pick up or call ahead for the day's offering
$1.75
Italian Soda PacksVarying flavors of all-natural no sodium sparkling Italian fruit Soda! Text/call to check our current flavors @ 574-276-6918
$8
BruschettiniItalian Toast is the perfect cheese friend. We carry Rosemary, EVOO, & Black Pepper. Customize at pick up or call ahead for available flavors
BreadOur Bread is yummy and made locally using either unbleached white flour, whole wheat flour, and/or organic bread flours and sometimes our cheese!
$3
Lasagne - largeStandard-size pan made from our farm & shop ingredients...simple goodness. Vegetarian or Meat depending on inventory text/call ahead if you need to confirm.
$35
Lasagne - smallA smaller version of our party pan though easily feeds 2 more with additional offering of antipasto, salad, dessert, etc. Vegetarian or Meat depending on our inventory, text/call ahead to confirm if necessary.
$15
Cannoli!Sweetened ricotta cheese with chocolate chips & candied fruit piped inside a double-thick fried shell from Sicily, yeeaah!
$2
Authentic Platter!Italian-style Antipasto Meats & Cheeses w/Olives & Edible Garnish on black plate w/domed lid for easy transport, stacking, and display. Our appetizers are made fresh using products available that day taking into account any dietary restrictions or requests. Please place this information in the notes
$65
Vegetarian & Fruit Platters!A mix of our on-hand Veggies, Fruits, Olives & Nuts with a Cheese or Vegan center on a 12" black plate w/domed lid. Please put dietary restrictions and requests in the notes or text/call at 574-276-6918!
$65
Cheese Platter!A variety of cheese in varying specie and textures w/Olives & edible seasonal garnish neatly displayed on a black plate w/domed lid for easy transport, stacking and display. Never exactly as pictured as we use what is readily available on make day, in-keeping with any dietary restrictions or request
$75
Vegan Catering!A tasty selection of Olives, Pickled Goodies, Raw Veggies, and more, centered around a cup of our favorite local Cashew Spread on a 12" platter with a domed lid. Text/Call for daily specifics at 574-276-6918 or leave a note with any dietary restrictions and requests when ordering online.
$75
Sub Platters!4-5 Subs with a pint of Tapenade or two 1/2-pints cut and plattered! Pictured Italian sub variations listed below, questions text/call @ 574.276.6918
$55
Merchandise
Gift BasketsAlways beautifully yummy a seasonal assortment of some of our favorite things!<br />If you have any special requests please let us know in the notes as well as recipient details i.e. family size, dietary restrictions, location, etc.
$50
Market ToteIdeal for filling at a Cheese Shop 😘 or Farmers Market OR for the Holidays! *Local Artwork on blue Cloth*
$20
T-Shirts2026 we brought back the Dark Side of the Cheese (J2K) and added a Rolling Stones band tee (Oh Mamma's). We still have 2025 Icarus, a take on Led Zeppelin’s Swan Song with melting Cheese. Sizes are Unisex so ladies sizing is 1 larger than tag. Put type & size in notes or text/call for availability,
$25
MagazineCulture, The Word On Cheese is a quarterly publication with everything you could ever want to know about cheese!<br />New Issues are $9.95, $3 off Newstand / Older issues are $5.00
$5
Drinks
Botanicals & KombuchaCircle Kombucha from IN (can) or GT's Sparkling Aqua Kefir from CA (glass) in varying flavors as well as regionalized drinks such as Fruit Belt Tonic!
$6
American SodaVariety of Coke & Pepsi products as well as sparkling Italian Soda containing low to no sodium & real fruit! Customize at pick up or call ahead for current flavors.
$2
Italian & Mexican Soda/Large Water/TeaFlavors vary week to week!
$3
Items
Date Night Platter!A scaled-down version of our antipasto platter. We will customize to your dietary requirements & requests. Leave a detailed message in the notes or call/text the Shop 574-276-6918 ♥ Please note, platter shape may vary but a heart-shaped cheese will be included in every purchase!
$45
Cheesemonger Plate - smallFeeds 1-2, a mix of cheese, meat, bread or cracker & edible garnish. Cheesemonger's choice though you can call ahead to semi-customize 574.276.6918
$13
Cheesemonger's Plate!Ready-to-Eat hand-cut specialties with half loaf of bread or equivalent crackers and edible garnish ~ 1 - 1.5 pounds cheesemonger's choice based on dietary restrictions or dislikes!<br />*Board not included.
$25
J2K Spread!Fresh goat (chevre) or cow (canzonetta) milk cheese. Goat is typically plain or Tuscan, Cow is typically Dill, Chipotle or Horseradish. Call for custom flavor or comment during online checkout.
$9
J2K FetaFresh cups of Feta - Farmhouse (cow) and Old French (goat) If applicable, list your preference in comments during online checkout.
$9
Pizza Kit!A semi-customizable Take & Make Pizza Kit 1 dough ball - White 1/2 cup sauce - Sweet or Savory (seasonal) 1 block melting Cheese - Mozz or Provo ~ 5-6 oz. 1 finishing Cheese - Artisan ~ 2-3 oz. 1 Topping Meat or Olive or Veggie 10 slices or 4oz. cup 1 Dessert - 5 Cannoli or 1 slice Tiramisu Let us c
$20
Three's a Party!3 J2K Cheeses - 1 Fresh Cup and 2 Aged Wedges or give us a call and we'll mix it up anyway you like! There are Goat & Cow milk options in most styles. Wedges are ~4-5 ounces / Cups are ~8 ounces. Call or text ahead for dietary requests and requirements
$25
Meat
Garlic Salamini/Pepperoni/GoatSalame piccante (red sticks) spicy but not hot. Genoa-style garlic & black pepper