Our classic butter cookie topped with smooth icing and sparkling sanding sugar, decorated as a bright red apple.
$4.89
A+ CookieOur signature butter cookie decorated with smooth icing and sanding sugar as an A+ graded paper.
$4.89
Pencil CookieA buttery cookie decorated with smooth icing and sanding sugar to resemble a classic school pencil.
$4.89
Gold Star CookieA buttery cookie decorated with smooth icing and shimmering gold sanding sugar, inspired by the classic gold star of achievement.
$4.89
Brownie
Decadent Fudge BrownieOur rich decadent brownies will have you forgetting that it is Gluten-Free. Each brownie is topped with ganache and a swirl of our signature chocolate buttercream and chocolate curls.
$5.99
Cake Slices
Everyday Wedding Cake SliceThree layers of moist vanilla almond cake filled with our signature buttercream. Created back in 2006 when a customer said he just wanted a slice of wedding cake.
$6.59
Chocolate Decadence Cake SliceCalling all chocolate lovers!! Do you LOVE all things chocolate? Me too!! Three layers of chocolate cake filled with dark chocolate frosting, sprinkled with chocolate cookie crumbles, iced in our chocolate signature buttercream. The texture combinations are truly decadent.
$6.99
Cannoli Cake SliceWhite cake brushed with an Italian Marsala syrup, filled with chocolate chip studded mascarpone frosting and cannoli cookie crumbs, topped with vanilla buttercream.
$6.99
Banana Bourbon Cake SliceBanana cake with bourbon caramel buttercream filling and icing
$6.99
Chocolate Dot CakeA fun, handheld dessert layered with your choice of rich chocolate or confetti cake, topped with smooth decorator’s icing and finished with colorful dot sprinkles. A playful, perfectly portioned treat for any sweet tooth!
$5
Confetti Dot CakeA fun, handheld dessert layered with your choice of rich chocolate or confetti cake, topped with smooth decorator’s icing and finished with colorful dot sprinkles. A playful, perfectly portioned treat for any sweet tooth!
$5
Gooey Butter
Gooey Butter SquareThis St. Louis specialty cake is a staple at every holiday celebration in our house. It’s slightly gooey, buttery and sweet. We take it a step further and add a dollop of our signature cream cheese frosting on top. You just have to try it to appreciate the obsession....
$4.99
Buttercream
Chocolate ButtercreamOne quart of our signature chocolate buttercream is enough is frost 12 cupcakes or 1-6" 2 layer cake. Please allow 24 hours to complete order
$20.95
Vanilla ButtercreamOne quart of our signature vanilla buttercream will be enough for 12 cupcakes or 1-6" 2 layer cake. Please allow 24 hours to complete order
$18.95
Traditional ButtercreamThis is the one that put us on the map! Our signature traditional buttercream has a hint of almond and is a favorite among our customers. This one quart container is enough to frost 12 cupcakes or 1-6" 2 layer cake. Please allow 24 hours to complete order
$18.95
Classic FrostingOur Classic Frosting is a delightful combination of sweet frosting and cream cheese frosting. This one quart container is enough to frost 12 cupcakes or 1-6" 2 layer cake.
$20.95
Daily Cupcakes
Carrot CupcakeSpiced cake baked with carrots, pineapple, coconut and pecans, topped with sweet cream cheese frosting.
$3.75
Classic CupcakeA delicious white confetti cupcake with a generous swirl of Sarah's Classic Icing and adorned with festive Sprinkles.
$3.75
Red Velvet CupcakeMoist and delicious Red Velvet cake with a swirl of Cream Cheese icing.
$3.75
Snack Cake CupcakeOur amazing Chocolate Cake filled with sweet frosting and topped with Vanilla Buttercream. We finish with a dip in our chocolate ganache and a festive Sarah's Squiggle.
$3.75
Triple Chocolate CupcakeOur rich chocolate cake is dolloped with chocolate fudge and then given a generous swirl of chocolate buttercream before finishing with a sprinkle of chocolate curls.
Golden Snack CupcakeA golden yellow cupcake filled with classic buttercream and topped with a fluffy vanilla buttercream poof, dipped in creamy white chocolate ganache. The golden counterpart to our classic Snack Cupcake, and just as delicious.
$3.75
Twix CupcakeA caramel cupcake with a buttery cookie bottom, chewy caramel filling, and a caramel buttercream poof dipped in chocolate ganache. Finished with a milk chocolate crumble for the ultimate Twix-inspired treat.
$3.75
Pumpkin CupcakePumpkin spice cupcake topped with rich, creamy cream cheese icing and a touch of cozy fall flavor.
$3.75
Vegan-ChocolateVegan Chocolate cake with a swirl of Vegan Vanilla Buttercream.
$4.25
Vegan-YellowVegan Vanilla cake with Vegan Vanilla Buttercream.
$4.25
Celebration Cakes
Vanilla Cream Celebration Cake2 Layers of Yellow Cake with Vanilla Buttercream. Serves 6-8 people. If you’d like your message in a specific color, please note it in the special request area.
$23.99
Everyday Wedding Celebration Cake2 Layers of Almond Cake with Almond Buttercream Filling & Icing. Serves 6-8 people. If you’d like your message in a specific color, please note it in the special request area.
$23.99
Mom's Traditional Celebration Cake2 Layers of Yellow Cake with Chocolate Buttercream Filling & Icing. Serves 6-8 people. If you’d like your message in a specific color, please note it in the special request area.
$25.99
Salted Caramel Celebration Cake2 layers of Caramel Cake with Caramel Buttercream filling, Chocolate Buttercream icing. Finished with a caramel and chocolate ganache drizzle. Serves 6-8 people.
$27.99
Snack Cake Celebration Cake2 Layers of Chocolate Cake filled with sweet frosting, iced in vanilla buttercream, drizzled with chocolate ganache. Serves 6-8 people. If you’d like your message in a specific color, please note it in the special request area.
$28.99
Triple Chocolate Celebration Cake2 layers of Chocolate Cake with Chocolate Fudge Filling. Iced with Chocolate Buttercream and sprinkled with Dark Chocolate Curls. Serves 6-8 people. If you’d like your message in a specific color, please note it in the special request area.
$26.99
Red Velvet Celebration Cake2 layers of Red Velvet cake with a Cream Cheese icing filling. Iced in Vanilla Buttercream. Served 6-8 people. If you’d like your message in a specific color, please note it in the special request area.
$26.99
Carrot Cake Celebration Cake2 layers of Carrot Cake with a Cream Cheese Icing filling. Iced in Vanilla Buttercream. Serves 6-8 people. If you’d like your message in a specific color, please note it in the special request area.
$30.99
Confetti Classic Celebration CakeA biggger version of our Classic Confetti Cupcake! White confetti cake with Classic Confetti filling (Buttercream & cream cheese icing mixed together with sprinkles) and Vanilla Buttercream icing on the outside. Serves 6 - 8.
$25.99
Marble Celebration CakeTwo layers of rich marble cake, swirled with chocolate and vanilla, filled with smooth chocolate buttercream and finished with a light, creamy vanilla buttercream for the perfect balance of flavors. Serves 6 - 8.
$30.99
Strawberry Jam white CakeTwo layers of soft white cake filled with sweet strawberry jam and finished with smooth vanilla buttercream. Serves 6–8 and makes a light, classic choice with a touch of fruit.
$24.99
Raspberry Jam white cakeTwo layers of soft white cake filled with bright raspberry jam and finished with smooth vanilla buttercream. Serves 6–8 and offers a classic vanilla base with a fresh, lightly tart twist.
$24.99
German Chocolate Celebration Cake
$29.99
Cannoli Celebration CakeA festive twist on a classic favorite! This 6-inch white cake is brushed with Italian Marsala syrup, layered with chocolate chip-studded mascarpone frosting and cannoli cookie crumbs, then finished with a smooth vanilla buttercream. It’s rich, creamy, and unforgettable—perfect for your next celebrat
$29.99
Cookies & Cream Celebration CakeChocolate cake filled with cookies & cream decadent filling and finished with vanilla buttercream icing. A classic combination for any celebration!
$26.99
Pumpkin Celebration Cake
$29.99
Standard Cakes
Vanilla Cream Standard CakeTwo delicious 9-inch layers of yellow cake with vanilla buttercream filling and icing. Add sprinkles and/or a message for a personal touch. Feeds 12–15. DESIGN CAN NOT BE CHANGED.
$45.99
Very Vanilla Standard CakeTwo delicious 9 inch layers of white cake with vanilla buttercream filling and icing. Add sprinkles and or a message for a personal touch. Feeds 12–15. DESIGN CAN NOT BE CHANGED.
$45.99
Everyday Wedding Standard CakeTwo delicious 9-inch layers of almond cake with almond buttercream filling and icing. Add sprinkles and/or a message for a personal touch. Feeds 12–15. DESIGN CAN NOT BE CHANGED.
$45.99
Red Velvet Standard CakeTwo delicious 9-inch layers of red velvet cake with cream cheese icing filling and a vanilla buttercream icing. Add sprinkles and/or a message for a personal touch. Feeds 12–15. DESIGN CAN NOT BE CHANGED.
$45.99
Double Chocolate Standard CakeOur Double Chocolate Standard Cake features two layers of moist chocolate cake, filled with smooth chocolate buttercream and finished with a generous coating of chocolate buttercream icing. At 9 inches, it’s the perfect centerpiece for celebrations or simply treating yourself to something decadent.
$58.50
Specialty Cakes
Vanilla Cream Specialty CakeThree 8-inch layers of yellow cake with vanilla buttercream filling and icing. Add sprinkles and/or a message for a personal touch. Feeds 18–20. DESIGN CAN NOT BE CHANGED.
$52.99
Very Vanilla Specialty CakeThree 8-inch layers of white cake with vanilla buttercream filling and icing. Add sprinkles and/or a message for a personal touch. Feeds 18–20. DESIGN CAN NOT BE CHANGED.
$52.99
Chocolate Birthday Specialty CakeThree 8-inch layers of chocolate cake with sweet frosting and chocolate milk crumb, finished in chocolate buttercream. Add sprinkles and/or a message for a personal touch. Feeds 18–20. DESIGN CAN NOT BE CHANGED.
$52.99
Everyday Wedding Specialty CakeThree 8-inch layers of almond cake with almond buttercream filling and icing. Add sprinkles and/or a message for a personal touch. Feeds 18–20. DESIGN CAN NOT BE CHANGED.
$52.99
Red Velvet Specialty CakeThree 8-inch layers of red velvet cake with cream cheese icing filling and vanilla buttercream icing. Add sprinkles and/or a message for a personal touch. Feeds 18–20. DESIGN CAN NOT BE CHANGED.
$52.99
Cookies
Chewy Goodness CookieThe best way to describe this cookie is crispy, buttery, chewy, chocolatey, the smell alone will get you excited for one bite. Customers drive from afar to get their fix and has quickly become a favorite.
$4.09
COOKIE Chocolate ChipOur signature chocolate chip cookie is crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. Packed with semi-sweet chocolate chips, with hints of caramelized sugar and butter.
$4.09
Chocolate Chip Mini DooziesTwo of our classic chocolate chip cookies filled with homemade American buttercream!
$2.99
Peanut Butter Chocolate Mini DoozieTwo soft, rich chocolate cookies filled with our smooth, creamy peanut butter icing for the perfect sweet-and-salty treat.
$2.99
Double Chocolate CookieA rich, indulgent cookie made with dark chocolate cookie dough, loaded with dark chocolate chips and chunks throughout. Every bite is packed with deep, bold chocolate flavor for a truly decadent all-dark-chocolate experience.
$4.09
Soft Iced CookieA soft butter cookie topped with a swirl of decorators icing and sprinkles. (A giant icing bite for those of us who remember them). Colors will vary!
$3.25
Chocolate Chip Cookie DoughOur homemade chocolate chip cookie dough is the perfect treat for any occasion! Made with rich butter, real vanilla, and loaded with plenty of semi-sweet chocolate chips, this dough is ready to bake or enjoy as-is. Whether you’re baking up a batch of fresh cookies or indulging in some raw dough, thi
$10
Butter Cookie DoughOur buttery, melt-in-your-mouth cookie dough is perfect for cutting shapes and decorating! With a smooth texture and rich flavor, it’s easy to roll and cut into your favorite designs. Plus, it’s simple to add sprinkles for a festive touch before baking. Whether you’re preparing for a special occasio
$10
Cookie Cake Slice - Vanilla DecNow you don’t have to wait for a party to enjoy a cookie cake! Our single chocolate chip cookie cake slices are the perfect way to treat yourself. Soft, chewy, and loaded with chocolate chips, then topped with just the right amount of frosting — it’s a little slice of happiness you can grab anytime.
$4.99
Flower Cookie
$4
Smiley Face CookieA buttery round cookie flooded with sweet icing and finished with a dip in sparkling sanding sugar. Designs and colors will vary, making each cookie a fun little surprise! 😊✨
$3.89
Glitter Bites & Truffles
Original Glitter Bite- Light PinkOur Glitter Bites are a customer favorite and a guaranteed crowd-pleaser! ✨ Two layers of moist white cake filled with vanilla buttercream, dipped in white chocolate, and rolled in shimmering sanding sugar. A truly magical, one-of-a-kind treat!
$2.15
Original Glitter Bite - WhiteThese decadent bites are a customer favorite and a guaranteed crowd pleaser. Our signature Glitter Bites are 2 layers of white cake filled with vanilla buttercream, dipped in white chocolate and rolled in sanding sugar. Truly magical and one of a kind!
$2.15
Seasonal Glitter Bite - Cookies & CreamA rich chocolate cake sphere filled with smooth fudge, dipped in white chocolate ganache, and rolled in a sparkling blend of white sanding sugar and cookie crumbs. Bite-sized, decadent, and dangerously good!
$2.25
Seasonal Glitter Bite - BiscoffA rich caramel cake sphere filled with salted caramel and Biscoff buttercream, dipped in smooth white chocolate ganache and rolled in shimmering sanding sugar.
$2.25
Seasonal Glitter Bite - PumpkinPumpkin cake sphere filled with spiced cream cheese, draped in white ganache, and rolled in yellow/orange sanding sugar
$2.25
Almond Cake TruffleAlmond cake truffles made from moist almond cake formed into bite-sized balls and coated in a smooth white chocolate shell, highlighting the rich almond flavor in every bite.
$2
Petit Fours
Double Chocolate Petit Four3 layers of almond cake with chocolate ganache and chocolate buttercream, covered in chocolate ganache.
$2.25
Strawberry Champagne Petit FourThree layers of almond cake filled with strawberry jam and champagne buttercream, and covered in white chocolate ganache.
$2.25
Cake Pops
Cake Pop- ChocolateChocolate cake truffle dipped in chocolate on a stick.
$2.25
Cake Pop- VanillaVanilla cake truffle dipped in white chocolate on a stick.
$2.25
Charcuterie Box
Favorites BoxIncludes: 1 Everyday Wedding Cake Slice, 1 Gooey Butter Square, 1 Snack Cake Cupcake, 4 Original Glitter Bites, 2 Double Chocolate Petit Fours, 2 Strawberry Champagne Petit Fours, 2 Chocolate Cake Pops, 2 Vanilla Cake Pops, & 4 Chocolate Chip Cookies Requires at least 24 hours to assemble and cannot
$49.99
Pastries
Peanut Butter Pumpkin Dog TreatsSpoil your pup with our delicious pumpkin dog treats! Made with simple, dog-friendly ingredients and baked to crunchy perfection, they’re a wholesome snack your furry friend will adore. Perfect for all breeds and sizes! (4 treats to a bag)