Turkey Bacon MeltHousemade Bacon Jam, Sharp Cheddar, Sliced Red Onion, Roasted turkey & house sauce on sourdough toasted with butter. Please allow for 7 minutes at least of preparation for maximum melty perfection.
$12
BYO Classic (LUNCH)
$4
Grilled CheeseCheddar & Swiss on toasty buttered multigrain sourdough
$9
Italian StallionThe one & only. House-sliced Capicola, Pepperoni, Mortadella, Salami, Provolone cheese, iceberg lettuce, marinated sliced tomato, red onion, basil/parsley, banana/roasted red pepper salad & mayo spread on a sesame ciabatta roll.
$12.50
Chicken Salad SandwichRoasted chicken salad mixed with Mayo, dijon & raisins, gem lettuce, marinated sliced tomato & mayo on sourdough.
$12
Bangin' BLTThick Cut Bacon, Marinated Sliced Tomato, Gem Lettuce & House Sauce on Multigrain Sourdough
$12
Turkey & RanchRoasted turkey, Avocado, Green ranch (more like a green goddess dressing), Mayo, Iceberg Lettuce & Marinated Sliced Tomato on sourdough.
$12
Half Sandwich/Side Combo MealEnjoy a half sandwich and a side of your choice. No modifications, sorry! **Turkey Melt and Grilled Cheese not eligible**
Coffee & Tea
ICED TeaYour choice of Dona Tea, brewed fresh hot or iced. Rising Green (supertwist green paired with lemongrass & mint) Assam (Black Tea) Chamomile Hibiscus (CAFFEINE FREE: hibiscus, chamomile blossoms, licorice root & mint)
$3.50
.Maple Oat Iced LatteReal grade A Maple syrup, brown sugar, oat milk & cold brew.
$4.25
Iced Matcha LatteOrganic matcha with oatmilk & sweetened with sugar. Batched latte served iced, no modifications--sorry!
$4.50
.Housemade Cold brewFresh made cold brew made with locally roasted beans. Delicious.
$4
Dona Chai Oatmilk LatteDona masala chai, cold brew & oatmilk sweetened with sugar.
$4.75
AGUA FRESCA ~*Tangerine, Lemon, ginger, lemongrass, cayenne*~On the rocks.
$4.75
Hot Drip Coffee (12oz.)12 ounces of locally roasted coffee served hot & fresh. Check out the merch section to buy whole bean coffee!
$3
Go-Go JuiceCold Brew Coffee topped with Tangerine Fresca. Refreshing!
$5
Box of Coffee96oz of a freshly roasted coffee blend to start your teams morning off right. Includes Cups, Sweeteners & Creamers
$28
HOT TEAYour choice of Dona Tea, brewed fresh and iced. Rising Green (supertwist green paired with lemongrass & mint) Earl Gray (Assam tea with lemon oil, bergamot & blue cornflower) Chamomile Hibiscus (CAFFEINE FREE: hibiscus, chamomile blossoms, licorice root & mint)
$3.50
Breakfast Sandwiches
Greek Feta & Olive SandwichSoft Omelette, Olive Tapenade, Marinated Tomato, French Feta, Red Onion, Roasted Red Pepper + Mayo on Toasty Focaccia Bun
$9.25
Bacon, Egg & CheddarToasty Focaccia bun, Thick cut bacon, Soft cooked omelette, Extra sharp cheddar and our house sauce. (The one Alton Brown had)
$9.25
Breakfast BLT3 Strips of thick cut bacon, soft cooked omelette, marinated sliced tomato, gem lettuce & house sauce on multigrain sourdough.
$12.75
Sausage, Egg & CheddarToasty Focaccia bun, house-made perfect breakfast sausage, Soft cooked omelette, Extra sharp cheddar and our house sauce.
$9.25
Egg SandwichSoft Omelette with Salt + Pepper on Focaccia Bun with House Sauce
$6.25
Avocado Toast (Sandwich)Delicious, lush avocado on a toasty Focaccia roll. Topped with Lemon, Mild Chili flake, sea salt, vegan mayo & extra virgin olive oil
$8.75
Beverages
Natalies Orange Juice
$4
Coke
$2.50
Diet CokeA Diet Classic.
$2.50
Gold Peak Sweet teaClassic Sweet Tea
$2.75
San Pellegrino Sparkling WaterVery Fresh and Earth Friendly.
$3.50
Jarritos Bottled SodaJuicy, refreshing...
$2.75
Spindrift Sparkling Water
$2.75
Bottled Water
$2
Soups, Sides & Chips
House Baked CookieFreshly baked in house and sprinkled with Maldon sea salt flakes. NOT vegan!
$3.75
Side salad **Vegan**Fresh Lettuce, Tomato & red onion tossed with fresh herbs and dressing of choice.
$4
Chips
$2
Fresh Marinated Cucumber & Herb Salad **Vegan**Crisp fresh cucumbers, ripe tomatoes, onions & picked fresh herbs. Topped with sesame greek seasoning.
$4
German Potato Salad **Vegan**Potatoes, sweet & vinegary caramelized onion, vegan mayo & chopped parsley. Try it with bacon!
$4
Tomato & Basil Soup **Vegan**Creamy roasty house-made tomato soup with a little kick of spice. Add bacon, croutons, or a side of bread if you fancy it!
$4
Lunch Combo UpgradeUpgrade your meal with a chips & drink combo.
$3.50
*MERCH*
Awning Shirt (Short + Long Sleeve)Tampa's favorite hole in the wall. Comfort Colors black short and long-sleeve t-shirt. Printed locally by Extra Medium Shirts.
$30
Whole Bean Coffee1 solid pound of small-batch roasted coffee from Original Brick Coffee in TPA. *10% of Profits from these beans supports the OBC Small communities grant* Originalbrickcoffee.com
$20
Awning HatTHE iconic shop awning embroidered on a 5-panel cap, crafted for comfort and sustainability. Quick-dry 100% recycled nylon. Includes an adjustable plastic fastener with elastic straps for a perfect fit. Embroidered in the bay area by Resilient Apparel.
$30
GUY SHIRTOne-of-a-kind SUPERFAN shirt with some Guy on it who seems to love Supernatural Donuts... Find out more on Season 55 Episode 4 of Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives
$30
Logo Tee (Single-Sided)NEXT LEVEL 100% COTTON TEE-SHIRT PRINTED IN FL BY RESILIENT APPAREL
$25
CAR MAGNETbeep beep: are you fed up with getting parking tickets AND want to rep supernatural big time? look no further! giant SN car magnets available 𝙉𝙊𝙒 𝙉𝙊𝙒 𝙉𝙊𝙒 for preorder!!! • 10" x 20" size meets city of tampa parking ordinances (but we can't guarantee they won't bust you anyway) • 4" x 11" is
$25
Awning Tote BagTHE Iconic awning on handy tote bag, printed locally by Extra Medium. 100% cotton tote bag.
$15
Drink Tumbler (16oz)16oz. Insulated drink tumbler featuring the best corner in Tampa Bay: E Polk St and N Franklin Ave
$25
GATOR TOP2-color front & back design on Ivory Comfort Colors Shirt, Available in short sleeve or tank top! Pre-order only, shirts will be delivered by end of June 2026!
$35
Shop KeychainKeep supernatural with you always <3 A little, acrylic donut shop for your keys, bags and trinket collections. Produced locally by Resilient Apparel.
$6
BAD BITCH DAD HAT100% Cotton, adjustable, washed denim
Fresh Classic SourDonuts!Housemade, light and tasty. Tossed in single origin spices & sugar. A new Classic Available Monday - Saturday
$2.75
Classic Vegan Sandwiches
The HubmarineMarinated & Roasted thin sliced tofu with Housemade pickles, iceberg lettuce, marinated sliced tomato & vegan house sauce on a toasty sesame ciabatta. Try it Dave's Way! (adds our house banana pepper/roasted red pepper salad, red onion, basil/parsley)
$12
Chickpea SandwichHousemade Roasted Chickpea salad (like a chunky zesty hummus!) on toasty sourdough with avocado, gem lettuce, marinated sliced tomato & a little green ranch (more like green goddess dressing). Try it Dave's Way! (adds our house banana pepper/roasted red pepper salad, red onion, basil/parsley)
$12
Garden Fresh Salads
House Chopped SaladRoasted Chicken, sliced avocado, a halved (perfect) boiled egg and chopped bacon on a bed of mixed greens with cucumber, red onion, and tomato topped with picked dill and parsley, Green Ranch (more like green goddess dressing), seasoned croutons and toasted sunflower seeds.
$11.50
Thai Crunch SaladRoasted Chicken or Marinated, Cubed Tofu on a bed of mixed greens with sliced avocado, cucumber, red onion, orange slices, shaved cabbage/carrot, charred cabbage, and a sprig of cilantro topped with Citrus Vinaigrette and our spicy sesame peanut crumble.
$11.50
Il Greco SaladRoasted Chickpea Salad on a bed of mixed greens with our delicious marinated olive medley, roasted red peppers, french feta, cucumber, red onion, and tomato topped with picked dill and parsley, red wine vinaigrette, and our sesame sumac topping
$11.50
**Weekly Specials**
PICADILLO SLOPPY JOEPICADILLO SLOPPY JOE Traditional picadillo with onions, raisins and potatoes. topped with plantain strips & served on toasty focaccia.