3 scoopsUp to 3 flavors. Please specify flavors of ice cream and sugar or cake cone or cup. Ice cream will not be served in the cone. Extra charge for toppings, plain or dipped waffle cones and bowls.
$8.50
2 scoops1 or 2 different flavors. Please specify ice cream flavor and sugar or cake cone or cup. Ice cream will not be served in the cone. Extra charge for toppings and waffle cone or bowl and dipped waffle cones or bowls.
$6.99
1 scoopPlease specify flavor of ice cream and cake, sugar cone or cup. Ice cream will not be served in the cone. Extra charge for plain and fancy dipped waffle cones and waffle bowls and toppings.
$4.99
FROM THE OVEN
Giant Fudge BrownieOur Giant house baked Fudge Brownie!
$4.50
Sundaes
Fudge Brownie SundaeOur Giant Fudge Brownie heated and topped with your choice of scoop, hot fudge, hot caramel, whipped cream and a cherry. Hot and cold items will be separated.
$9.50
Small SundaeOne scoop and one topping of your choice served with whipped cream and a cherry. Please chose your topping from the SUNDAE TOPPINGS LIST. If you would like to add another topping use the ADD TOPPINGS LIST.
$6.95
Medium Sundae2 scoops (up to two flavors) and 2 toppings your choice served with whipped cream and a cherry. Please chose your 2 toppings from the SUNDAE TOPPINGS LIST. If you would like to add another topping use the ADD TOPPINGS LIST.
$9.50
Large Sundae3 scoops (up to 3 flavors) and 3 toppings your choice served with whipped cream and a cherry. Please chose your 3 toppings from the SUNDAE TOPPINGS LIST. If you would like to add another topping use the ADD TOPPINGS LIST.
$11.99
Buddha Belly Sundae5 scoops (up to 5 flavors) and 5 toppings your choice served with whipped cream and a cherry.
$15.95
Reese’s Sundae2 scoops your choice topped with hot fudge, peanut butter sauce, Reese pieces, whipped cream and a Reese Cup. A Tilly’s Favorite.
$9.50
Ice Cream Nachos3 scoops and 3 toppings your choice served with rainbow sprinkles, whipped cream, cherries and a large side of waffle cone chips for dipping.
$13.95
S’mores Sundae2 scoops your choice topped with Hershey’s syrup, marshmallow sauce, mini marshmallows, graham crackers crumbs, whipped cream and chocolate flakes.
$9.95
Reese Cup Brownie SundaeOur house baked fudge brownie heated and topped with a huge scoop of your choice, hot fudge, peanut butter sauce, Reese’s pieces, whipped cream and a Reese Cup! Warm and cold will be packaged separately.
$9.95
Party Packs
Party Pack 20Includes: 6 Quarts of your choice, 20 waffle cones, 6 large toppings, 2 cans of whipped cream and a cup of maraschino cherries!
$200
Party Pack 30Includes: 9 Quarts. 30 waffle cones, 8 Large Toppings, 3 cans of whipped cream and a big cup of maraschino cherries!
$275
Party Pack 10Includes: 3 Quarts of your choice, 10 waffle cones, 6 toppings, 1 can of whipped cream and a cup of maraschino cherries!
$115
Shakes, Malts and Floats
Traditional Float2 big scoops your choice served with an ice cold Coke, Orange Soda, Root beer or any other canned soda available.
$7.75
MaltYour choice of ice cream mixed with old fashioned malt served with whipped cream and a cherry.
$8.50
Milk ShakeA 16 ounce thick shake served with whipped cream and a cherry.
$7.95
Specialty Float2 big scoops your choice served with a cold bottle of Boylan Black Cherry Soda topped with whipped cream and a cherry. Ice cream and soda will be served separately.
$8.50
Kids Favorites
Cone headKid's choice scoop, sugar cone hat, whipped cream collar, cherry nose and rainbow sprinkles!
$5.95
Cookie MonsterKid's choice scoop, oreo crumbs, blue sprinkles and a chocolate chip cookie.
$5.95
The Sugar Rush1 scoop kids choice topped with fruity pebbles and real cotton candy.
$5.95
Unicorn sundae1 scoop kids choice topped with rainbow sprinkles, crunchy rainbow marshmallows and a giant unicorn marshmallow.
$5.95
Dirt sundae1 scoop Kids Choice topped with “dirt” chocolate crumbs and gummi worms.
$5.95
CUSTOM ICE CREAM PIES
CUSTOM ICE CREAM PIECreate your own Tilly's Ice Cream Pie! Chose a Chocolate, Graham Cracker or GF Chocolate Crust, layered with up to 2 flavors and 2 toppings. 24 Hours notice required MOST OF THE TIME! Need it faster? Call the store at 540-377-4033 and we will do our best to accommodate you! Feeds 1-12! These pies ar
$60
Pints and Quarts
Pint to goPint of your choice! Need cones or toppings? Feel free to add them to your order!
$10
Quart1 Quart pick your flavor! Need cones or toppings? Feel free to add them on!
$18
Menu
Strawb Banana Shake
$8.50
Berry Blast Float
$8.95
Blueberry Crumble Biscoff Parfait
$9.50
Peach Crumble Parfait
$9.50
Pumpkin cookie
$3.50
BYO WAFFLE SUNDAE
$9.95
Cherry Coke Deluxe Float
$8.50
Celsius
$3
St. Patrick’s Day Shake
$7.95
Donut Sundae 🍩
$8.50
Pineapple 🍍 Strawberry 🍓 Waffle
$9.95
Eggnog Cream Pie
$18
Shark Attack Parfait
$9.50
Sale Pint
$6.50
Blackberry crumble parfait
$9.50
Caramel Apple Sundae
$9.50
Lucky Leprechaun Sundae
$5.95
Strawberry pineapple waffle sundae
$9.95
Fudge Mint Oreo Nachos
$13.95
Waffle Sundae
$9.95
St. Patty’s Hot Cocoa
$7.95
Irish Coffee
$7.95
Cake and Ice Cream Sundae
$7.95
Raspberry Brownie Parfait
$9.50
Red, White, and Blue Shortcake Sundae
$9.50
Orange Pineapple Blast Float
$8.95
S’mores Parfait
$9.50
Samplers
12 scoop Sampler12 full scoops your choice served in a cupcake container so all scoops are separated.
$32
4 scoop sampler4 full scoops your choice served in a cupcake container so they do not touch.
$13
Ice Cream Sandwich Sampler4 chocolate wafer ice cream sandwiches with your choice of up to 4 flavors!
$12
Pup Cup
Pup CupHouse made combo of blended bananas, peanut butter and coconut milk served frozen and topped with coconut whipped cream, peanut butter drizzle and a dog cookie. 50% of pup cup sales donated every month to a different animal charity.
$3.50
Drinks
Water bottle
$1.50
SodaChoose from Coke, Sunkist Orange, Sunkist Grape and A n W Rootbeer.
$1.75
Special Sodas
$3.50
Online Menu
Homemade Caramel Pecan Pie and A QuartOur perfect homemade pecan pie drizzled with caramel and a quart of your choice! Pick up is Sunday 12/21 2-8pm or Wednesday 12/26 2-6pm. Please make sure to choose your ice cream flavor.
$37.50
Homemade Apple PieHomemade with granny smith apples, cinnamon, nutmeg, sugar and butter. Sweet and tart with a beautiful decorative crust! Please choose baked or unbaked!
$30
Peppermint Bark Sky High Ice Cream PieA chocolate crust layered with peppermint stick ice cream, dark chocolate flakes, hot fudge, whipped topping and peppermint bark! Pick up is Sunday 12/21 from 2-8pm or Wednesday 12/26 from 2-6pm.
$45
Homemade Caramel Pecan PieA perfect homemade pecan pie packed with pecans and drizzled with caramel! Please note Pick up is Sunday 12/21 2-8pm or Wednesday 12/26 from 2-6pm.
$22.50
Homemade Apple Pie a Quart of Ice CreamHomemade apple pie made with granny smith apples, sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg and butter. Sweet and tart with a beautiful decorative crust! Comes with a quart of your favorite ice cream. Please choose baked or unbaked for your pie and your ice cream flavor. Pick up is Sunday 12/21 between 2-8pm or Wedne