Paul's Island Sampler4 wings, Paul's wicked pickles, and garlic cheese curds with ranch
$16
Tuna StackableCajun seared tuna, spring mix, teriyaki glaze, scallions, toasted pita, and cucumber wasabi for dipping
$18
Cajun Fish BitesFried mahi bites breaded with Cajun seasoning served with horseradish mayo
$13
Paul’s Wicked PicklesPickle chips brined in our house-made Carolina Reaper sauce, lightly fried, and served with a side of ranch (our Reaper sauce is no joke—these are spicy!).
$9
Garlic Cheese CurdsCheese curds served with ranch
$11
Fried ClamsFried clams on a bed of spring mix served with cocktail sauce and lemon (tartar sauce on request)
$11
Pinch + Eat ShrimpSemi-peeled shrimp tossed in Chesapeake Bay seasoning served with cocktail sauce and melted butter
$10
Soups & Salads
Tomato SoupOur classic tomato soup is back!
$8
Taco SaladLettuce, seasoned ground beef, black beans, pico de gallo, sour cream, cilantro vinaigrette, and shredded cheese in a tortilla bowl
$16
Chef Ron's WedgeIceberg lettuce, hard-boiled eggs, crispy shallots, bacon, parmesan, blue cheese dressing, and croutons
$14
Beet and Goat Cheese SaladBeets, candied walnuts, spring mix, goat cheese with an orange balsamic vinaigrette
$14
Grilled Chicken Caesar SaladGrilled chicken, romaine, parmesan cheese, croutons, and Caesar dressing
$18
Menu
WingsFried wings tossed with your choice of sauce
$12
Fried RibsFried ribs tossed with your choice of sauce
$15
Calabash PlatterFlounder, shrimp, and clam strips battered and fried, served with tartar sauce, cocktail sauce, fries, white slaw, and lemon wedge
$29
Popcorn Shrimp PlatterShrimp battered and fried served with tartar sauce, cocktail sauce, fries, white slaw, and lemon wedge
$19
Cajun Chicken PastaCajun chicken over tortellini tossed in a rich cream sauce and served with bread
$20
Fish and ChipsBeer-battered cod with tartar sauce served with fries, white slaw, and lemon wedge
$19
Sauces
BuffaloThe classic, done properly
Atomic Carolina ReaperOur already intense Carolina Reaper sauce + fresh chilies and powders *this sauce is seriously no joke*
Cheerwine BBQ SauceCheerwine, BBQ sauce
Spicy Lemon PepperOur popular buffalo sauce mixed with our lemon pepper dry rub
Thai Hot Honey SauceThai pepper, honey, habanero
Paul's Signature Double Smash Burger
DoubleNone
$21
SingleNone
$16
Set Options
All the WaySlaw, chili, onions, American cheese, King’s Hawaiian bun
$21
Black & BleuBlackened with bleu cheese, King's Hawaiian bun
$21
Mushroom SwissMushroom and Swiss, King's Hawaiian bun
$21
Backyard ClassicLettuce, tomato, onion, American cheese, and mayonnaise, King's Hawaiian bun
$21
FirehousePepper Jack & candied jalapenos, King's Hawaiian bun
$21
Impossible Smash BurgerStarter plant-based smash burger on a King’s Hawaiian bun. Build it your way
$23
Build Your OwnStarter smash burger on a King's Hawaiian bun. Build it your way
$21
Add OnsNone
Handhelds
Patty MeltGrilled ground beef, house-made Thousand Island dressing, caramelized onions, and Swiss cheese on toasted sourdough bread
$17
Shrimp QuesadillaGrilled shrimp, shredded cheddar cheese on toasted tortilla served with pineapple salsa and cilantro sour cream
$15
Mediterranean Steak WrapTender steak, rice, tomatoes, smoked feta, black olives, and tzatziki sauce in a toasted wrap
$16
Smash SausageSausage, over-easy egg, and American cheese
$15
Mahi SandwichBlackened mahi served with lettuce, tomato, and onion
$18
Chicken SandwichBoneless thighs, fried or grilled. Choose a set option or build your own!
$16
Hot DogsAll-beef hot dogs (2). Choose a set option or build your own!
$12
BLTThick-cut bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on white bread
$13
Sides
White SlawCabbage, mayo, apple cider vinegar
$4
French FriesSeasoned crinkle cut fries
$4
Seasoned RiceItalian seasoning, butter, S & P
$4
Side SaladSpring mix, red onion, grape tomato, cucumber, carrot, croutons, and your choice of dressing
$5
EsquitesGrilled corn topped with shaved cotija cheese, garlic aioli, cilantro, paprika, and green onion
$5
Collard GreensSouthern style with bacon
$5
Sweet Finishes
Dessert TrioA trio of induglence—slices of limoncello cake, banana coconut cake, and NY turtle cheesecake finished with whipped cream
$21
Dense Chocolate CakeA slice of dark, moist chocolate cake layered with smooth chocolate filling, serves 2 people
$15
New York Turtle CheesecakeWith caramel sauce
$8
Limoncello CakeWith raspberry sauce
$8
Banana Coconut CakeNone
$8
Non-Alcoholic
Athletic - Upside Down, <.5%, Golden Ale, CT, 12 OzNon-alcoholic Golden Ale is pale orange in color with aromas and flavors of cereal grain, banana, and lemon