Best ice cream in Fayetteville
101 places · updated Nov 2026
#1
Handel's Homemade Ice Cream - York, PA
$4.75
4.6 · 333 ratings#2
Dairy Queen
$2.30
3.8 · 38 ratings
99 more · not ranked yet
- $1.99–8.95
- $6.29–7.82
- $4.99–7.99
- $2.99–6.99
- $2.99–6.99
- $4–14
- $3–7