Best Italian food in Madison
285 places · updated Nov 2026
#1
Jet's Pizza
4.6 · 115 ratings
284 more · not ranked yet
- $8.25–225
Pizza Pit2 Spaghetti's + 1 Order Garlic Bread +159 more $6.99–35.78- $8.25–225
- $10–26.50
- $10–26.50
- $9.49–35.59
- $6.50–26.99
- $4.35–26
- $11.50–26.50
- $3.59–123
Sbarro17" NY Pepperoni +40 more $10.99–39.99